k-Xy-ta-h- P-b-tX-...

(t\m-h-se-äv-)-

(By C.A. Chacko, Advocate, Ernakulam)

 

H-cp- sk-¡³-dv- A-¸o-en-se- hm-Z-n-bm-Wv- Cu- I-Y-bn-se- \m-b-I³-.- (Cu- I-Y-bn-se- FÃm-h-cpw- sh-dpw- km-¦Â-]n-Iw- am-{X-a-Ã.- bm-Zr-iv-Nn-I-X- kzm-`m-hn-I-w.- H-cp- kzm`m-hn-I- a-\pjy- Pohn-Xw- t]m-se...)-

 

H-¶v-

F-d-Wm-Ip-fw-

16.-8.-2006

\m-cm-b-W-]-Wn-¡À-¡v,-

Xm-¦Ä- GÂ-¸n-¨n-cp-¶- A-¸oÂ- 30.-8.-06\v- _-lp.- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- hm-Z-¯n-\p- h-¨n-cn-¡p-¶p.- Cu- I-¯v- In-«n-bm-ep-S³- h-¡o-em-¸o-kp-am-bn- _-Ô-s¸-Sp-hm³- XmÂ]-cy-s¸-Sp-¶p.-

F-¶v,-

(H-¸v-)-

      A-Uz-t¡-äv- ¢À-¡v-

 

H-ä-¡m-e³- I-«n-¡-®-S-bp-sS- I-®n-eq-sS- \m-cm-b-W-]-Wn-¡À- Cu- I-¯v- hm-bn-¡p-hm³- hm-kp-hn-s³-d- Nm-b-¡-S-bnÂ- \n-¶pw- ho-Sp-h-sc- D-Å- k-a-bw- F-Sp-¯p.-

""Pm-\-Io- \-½p-sS- tI-kv- 30.-8.-06\v- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- hm-Z-¯n-\v- h-¨n-cn-¡p-¶p.''

ho-«n-te-¡v- ImÂ- F-Sp-¯v- h-bv-¡p-¶-Xn-\p-ap-t¶- ]-Wn-¡À- `m-cy-sb- hn-fn-¨v- Im-cyw- ]-d-ªp.-

ho-Sn-s³-d- ]n-¶n-se- ]-Sn-¡Â- Nq-en-\v- CuÀ-¡nÂ- Io-dn-s¡mI-­n-cp-¶- Pm-\-In- D-¯-cw- H-¶pw- ]-d-ªn-Ã.- h-f-sc- \nÀ-hn-Im-c-X-tbm-sS- tI-«n-cp-¶ Pm-\-In-bp-sS- A-Sp-t¯-¡v- ]-Wn-¡À- sN-¶p.- h¡o-en-s³-d- A-dn-bn-¸v- ImÀ-Uv- Im-Wn-¨p.-

 

""F-d-Wm-Ip-f-s¯- h-¡o-em-¸o-knÂ- \n-¶m- A-dn-bn-¨n-cn-¡p-¶-Xv.- a-p-¸-Xmw- Xo-b-Xn- hm-Zw- B-W-s{X-.'' h-f-sc- B-Ëm-Z-t¯m-sS-bm-Wv- ]-Wn-¡À- `m-cy-tbm-Sv- ]-d-ª-Xv.- Pm-\-In-bp-sS- \n-Êw-K-X- ]Wn-¡-sc- th-Z-\n-¸n-¨p.-

""sk-¡³-d¸o-ev- ^-b-enÂ- kzo-I-cn-¡p-hm³- X-¡-Xm-b- \n-b-a-{]-iv-\w- D-s­-I¶m-Wv- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-ev- ]-d-ª-Xv.- XoÀ-¨-bm-bpw- \-½p-sS- tI-kv- hm-Zw- tI-«v- hn-[n-]-d-bpw''.-

 

ho-­Ipw- `m-cy-sb- k-t´m-jn-¸n-¡p-hm³- ]-Wn-¡À- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\- D-²-cn-¨p- ]-d-ªp-sImI-­n-cp-¶p...-

 

aq-¯-a-I-sf- {]-k-hn-¨p- In-S-¡p-t¼m-gm-Wv- tIm-S-Xn- tI-kn-s\-¡p-dn-¨v- ]-Wn-¡À- B-Zy-am-bn- `m-cy-tbm-Sv- ]-d-ª-Xv-.- H-ä-¸m-ew- ap³-kn-^v- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- sam-gn-sIm-Sp-¯v- B-ip-]-{Xn-bnÂ- F-¯n-b- ]-Wn-¡À- B-Zyw- `m-cy-tbm-Sv- ]-d-ª-Xv- tI-kn-\p- sam-gn-sIm-Sp-¯-Im-cy-am-Wv.- `m-cy-bp-sS- A-Sp-¯v- In-S-¡p-¶- X-s³-d- k-oa-´-]p-{Xn-sb- ]-Wn-¡À- B-Zy-am-bn- {i-²n-¡p-¶-Xv- tI-kp-Im-cyw- ]-d-ªp- XoÀ-¯-Xn-\p-ti-jw- am-{X-am-Wv-.- Ip-ªn-s\- I-¿n-Â- F-Sp-¯v- Ip-ªn-s³-d- ap-J-¯p-t\m-¡m-sX- ]Wn-¡À- `m-cy-tbm-Sp- ]-d-ªp-:-

 

""\-½-fp- P-bn-¡pw- Pm-\-Io,-- \-½p-sS- tI-kv- P-bn-¡pw-''.

]-Wn-¡À- H-cp- N-S-§p-t]m-se- Ip-«n-sb- Pm-\-In-bp-sS- A-Sp-¯v- In-S-¯n.-

 

A-¶v- Xp-S-§n-b-Xm-Wv- Pm-\-In-bp-sS- \n-Ê-w-K-X-.- aq-¯-a-IÄ-¡n-t¸mÄ- 33 h-b-Êm-bn.- A-hÄ-¡v- 2 Ip-«n-I-fm-bn.- 33 hÀ-j-¯n-\n-S-bnÂ- F-{X-tbm- X-h-W-IÄ- F-{X-tbm- A-h-[n-IÄ- tI-kn-s\-¡p-dn¨v- ]-Wn-¡À- ]-d-ªn-cn-¡p-¶p.-

 

""]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-ev- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- P-Uv-Pn- B-tII-­- B-fm.- A-ªq-dp-dp-¸n-I- tI-kv- _-©nÂ- h-cp-¯n-¡m³- Kp-a-kv-X³- ^o-kv- hm-§n-¨-t¸mÄ- ]-d-ª-Xm''.

 

Pm-\-In- ]-Wn-¡À- ]-d-ª-Xp- tIÄ-¡m-sX- F-gp-t¶-äv- A-I-t¯-¡v- t]m-bn.-

"'c-­Ip-tIm-S-Xn-I-fpw- X-Ån-b- hm-Z-am-Wv.- H-cp-]m-Sv- ]-Wn-bpI-­v.- samg-n- ]-IÀ-¸pw- hn-[n-]-IÀ-¸pw- ]-Tn-¡-Ww.- B-[m-c-hpw- {]-am-W-§-fpw- ]-Tn-¡-Ww.- I-gn-ª-Im-e- hn-[n-IÄ- h-¨v- hm-Zw- \-S-¯-Ww.- \n-b-a-{]-iv-\w- kr-jv-Sns¨-Sp-¡-Ww.- Xm-sg- tIm-S-Xn-bn-se- A-tX- tImÀ-«p-^o-kp- sI-«-Ww.- Iq-Sm-sX- h-¡oÂ-^o-kv- 30,-000/-þ cp-]-bm-Ipw....- B-Zyw- 20,-000/þ X-c-Ww.- tI-kv- ]-cn-K-W-\-bv-¡p-h-cp-¶- Zn-h-kw- ImÀ-U-b-¡pw...- A-Xn-\p- ap³-]v- _m-¡n- 10,-000/þ cq-]- F-¯n-¡-Ww''.-

 

`m-cy- A-I-t¯-¡v- t]m-b- iq-\y-X-bnÂ- t]m-kv-ävImÀ-UnÂ- t\m-¡n-b- ]-Wn-¡-sc- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h¡o-en-s³-d- hm-¡p-IÄ- HmÀ-½n-¸n-¨p.-

]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- ap-J-¯v- km-h-[m-\w- G-tXm- H-cp- B-[n- ]-SÀ-¶p.-

""20,-000/þ cq-]-sIm-Sp-¯-Xv- Pm-\-In-bp-sS- B-§-f-bp-sS- Ø-ew- hn-än-«m-Wv.- C-\n- Rm³- F-hn-sS- \n-¶v- 10,-000/þ cq-]- DI-­m-¡pw.- 30þmw- Xo-b-Xn-¡p-ap-¼v- ]-Ww- F-¯n-¡-Ww.-''

 

]n-jm-c-Sn h-¡o-en-s³-d- ^o-kp- ]-d-bp-¶- ap-J-am-Wv- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- a-\-Ên-en-t¸mÄ.- F-{X- emL-h-t¯m-sS-bm-Wv- h-¡oÂ- ^o-kv- ]-d-bp-¶-Xv.- \n-b-a-{]-iv-\w- I-­Ip- ]n-Sn-¡m-\p-Å- ^o-km-Wv- þ Substantial Question of Law.

 

""F-s³-d- ^o-kv- h-f-sc-Ip-d-hm-Wv-. Rm³- \n-§-sf-t¸m-ep-Å-h-tcm-Sv- F-s³-d- ]-Wn-¡p-Å- ^okv- t]m-epw- hm-§m-dn-Ã''.-

h-¡oÂ- X-s³-d- F-fn-a-sImI-­v- A-l-¦-cn-¨-Xv- A-bm-fq-sS- \-Ã- a-\-Êm-bn-t«- ]-Wn-¡À-¡p- tXm¶n-bp-Åq.-

 

H-c-p-h-iw- N-cn-ªv- In-g-t¡m-«v- Nm-ªp- \nÂ-¡p-¶- ho-Sn-s³-d- ]-Sn-ªm-sd- A-ä-s¯- Xq-WnÂ- Xm-§n- ho-«n-te-¡v- ]-Wn-¡À- I-b-dn-b-Xv- F-t´m- H-¶v- \n-\-¨p-d-¨-t]m-s-e-bm-bn-cp-¶p.-

""\n-§Ä- tI-kp- \-S-¯n- F-Ãmw- X-p-e-¨p.- C-\n- B-sI-bp-Å-Xv- Cu- Xm-en-am-e- am-{X-am-Wv.- AsX-s¶- Xo-¿nÂ- h-¨n-t«- \n-§Ä-¡p- sImI-­p-t]m-hm³- H-¡q''.

A-I-¯p-\n-¶pw- Pm-\-In-bp-sS- A-eÀ-¨- tI-«p.-

""F-¶m-epw- Pm-\-In- \-½-fp- P-bn-¡pw- P-bn-¡m-Xn-cn-¡n-Ã''.-

B-Zy-s¯- tZ-jyw- am-{X-ta- Pm-\-In-¡p-Åq- F-¶pw- ]n-s¶-¸n-s¶- Xm³- ]-d-bp-¶-Xn-\-¸p-dw- Zm¼-Xy-tc-J-bnÂ- \n-¶pw- H-cn-S am-dn-Ã-sb-¶pw- 35 hÀ-j-s¯- H-cp-an-¨p-Å- Po-hn-Xw-sImI-­v- ]-Wn-¡À-¡p-d-¸m-bn-cp-¶p.-

 

cIv-­v-

 

hm-Zn-{]-Xn-I-fp-sS- hm-Z-{]-Xn-hm-Z-§-fnÂ- \n-¶pw- \n-b-a-{]-iv-\w- I-­Ip-]n-Sn-¡p-¶- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- h-¡o-e-·m-cp-sS- _p-²n- A-]m-cw- X-s¶...- hm-Zn- A-\ym-b-¯nÂ- ]-d-bp-¶- Im-cy-§Ä- \n-b-a-h-im-tem- Im-cy-h-im-tem- \n-e-\nÂ-¡-¯-¡-X-Ã,- Xm-sg- hy-à-am-bn- k½--Xn-¡p-¶sXm-gn-sI- _m-¡n- k-I-e- Im-cy-§-fpw- {]-Xn- \n-tj-[n-¡p-¶p,- F-¶p- Xp-S-§p-¶- ]-{Xn-I-hm-bn-¡p-t¼mÄ- hm-Zn-bp-sS- N-¦n-Sn-¨p-t]m-Ipw.- F-¶n-«pw- F-{X- Iq-ken-Ãm-sX-bm-Wv- h-¡o-e-·mÀ- A-Xv- ssI-Im-cyw- sN-¿p-¶-Xv....-

 

sh-fp-¸n-\v- 5.-25\v- sjmÀ-®q-cnÂ- \n-¶pw- F-d-Wm-Ip-f-t¯-¡v- ]p-d-s¸-«- ]m-k-©À- s{S-bn³- s]cn-bm-dp- I-S-¡p-t¼m-gm-Wv- ]-Wn-¡À- h¡o-e-·m-sc-¡p-dn-¨p-Å- a-l-Xv- Nn-´-I-fnÂ- \n-¶pw- D-WÀ-¶-X-v.-

 

s{S-bn-\nÂ- \n-¶p-Nm-Sn- F-gp-t¶-äv- s\-©nÂ- ssI-h-¨v- I-®pI-f-S-¨v- in-h-cm-{Xn- a-W-¸p-d-t¯¡v- Xn-cn-ªv- F-Ã-m-B-Xv-am-¡-sf-bpw- {]-tXy-In-¨v- X-s³-d- A-½-sb- ]-Wn-¡À- HmÀ-¯p.- ]m-ew- I-S-¶- H¨-bpw- _-lf-hpw- I-gn-ªv- I-®p-Xp-d-¡p-t¼mÄ- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- lr-Z-b-¯nÂ- \n-¶pw- H-cp-Xp-Ån- I®oÀ- ]-p-d-¯p-h-¶p.-

 

""\o-bm-Wv- F-Ãmw- t\m-¡n- \-S-¯n-b-Xvv- s]-§-·m-sc- sI-«n-¨-b-¨p.- \n-\-¡pw- H-cp- Po-hn-Xw- tht­I.- F-Ãm-w- hn-äv- C-\n- _m-¡n-bp-Å- 20 sk³-dpw- ho-Spw- \n-s³-d- t]À-¡v- Rm³- hnÂ-]-{Xw- Fgp-Xm³- D-t±-in-¡m-Wv-''.

 

C-f-b- s]-§-sf- sI-«n-¨-b-¨v- h-c-hv- sN-e-hp- I-W-¡p-IÄ- t\m-¡n- \nÂ-s¡- X-s³d- A-½- tZ-h-In- ]-d-ª- hm-¡p-IÄ...- 33 hÀ-j-s¯- hm-Z-{]-Xn-hm-Z-§-fpw- hn-[n-I-fpw- HmÀ-¯v- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³d- B-¸o-knÂ- F-¯p-t¼mÄ- Kp-a-kv-X-\m-Wv- ]-Wn-¡-sc- kzo-I-cn-¨-Xv.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-sc- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- ^-bÂ- F-¯n-¡-Ww- sN-e-hp-IÄ- h-cpw.- cm-hn-se-X-s¶- tI-kp- hnfn-¸n-¡-Ww.- P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- hSn-sb- Im-W-Ww.- H-cp- 300/þ cq-]- sN-e-hp- h-cpw-''.

 

`m-cy-bp-sS- Xm-en-am-e-hn-äp-In-«n-b- 8,-500/þ cq-]-bpw- ]-e-tcm-Sm-bn- I-Sw- hm-§n-h-¨- 1,-500/þ cq-]-bpw- Iq-«n- 10,-000/þ cq-]- ¹m-kv-än-Iv- I-h-dnÂ- Nm-¡p-N-c-Sn-s³-d- _-e-¯nÂ- sI-«n-bp-d-¸n-¨mWv- ]-Wn-¡À- F-¯n-bn-cn-¡p-¶-Xv.- I-Sw- hm-§n-¨- 100/þ cq-]- hI-­-n-¡m-ipw.-

 

Kp-akv-X-s³-d- hm-¡p-IÄ- H-cn-Sn-sh-«p-t]m-se- ]-Wn-¡-sc- sR-«n¨-p.-

70 hÀ-jw- Nn-cn-¨- tam-W- ho-­Ipw- H-¶p-Iq-Sn- Xp-d-¶p- Im-«n- Nn-cn-¨v- ]-Wn-¡À- Kp-a-kv-X-s\- t\cn-«p.-

 

B-¸o-knÂ- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- \n-g-ep-II-­-t¸mÄ- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- D-d-s¡- hn-fn-¨p...-

 

""]-Wn-¡-tc...- h-¶m-epw-. C-¶-dn-bmw- Xs³-d- K-Xn...- 55 sIm-Ã-s¯- F-Ãm- hn-[n-I-fpw- ]-Tn-¨v- Rm³- \n-b-a- {]-iv-\w- kr-jv-Sn-¨n-«pI-­v.- _m-¡n- ss]-k- X-t¶m-fq...-''

 

ss]-k- tNm-Zn-¡m³- th-In- am-{X-am-Wv- 55 sIm-Ã-s¯- Im-cyw- ]-d-ª-sX-¶v- ]-Wn-¡À- A-dn-bp-¶pI-­m-hp-tam?-

 

X-s³-d- _-\n-b-s³-d- D-ÅnÂ- \n-¶pw- ¹m-kv-än-Iv- I-hÀ- F-Sp-¯v- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\- GÂ-¸n-¡p-t¼mÄ- ]-Wn-¡À- X-s³-d- Pm-\-In-bp-sS- a-\-Êm-Wv- k-aÀ-¸n-¡p-¶-sX-¶v- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- A-dn-ªn-cp-¶n-Ã.-.....- `-K-h-m-s\³- a-\-Êpw- X-cmw...-

 

ss]-k- I-¿nÂ- In-«n-b-Xpw- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- ap-Jw- H-¶p- sX-fn-ªp.-

""]-Wn-¡À- ]-p-d-¯n-cp-t¶-m-fq. Rm³- tI-kp- ]-Tn-¡-s«....- C-¶v- D-{K-hm-Z-am-Wv- \n-§-fp-sS- tIkn -''.

B-Zy-am-bn tIm-S-Xn-Ib-dp-¶- Pq-\n-bÀ- h-¡oÂ- tIm-S-Xn-sb- sXm-gp-¶-Xp-t]m-se- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h¡o-en-s\- sXmgp-Xv- ]-Wn-¡À- ]-p-d-¯n-cp-¶p.-

]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- ta-i-s_Â-tI-«v- Pq-\n-bÀ- h-¡oÂ- A-t±-l-¯n-s³-d- ap-dn-bn-te-¡v- I-S-¶p-sN-¶p.-

""You seek an adjournment for this second appeal. F-\n-¡p- kp-J-an-Ã- F-¶p-]-d''

]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- tI-kp-sI-«v- F-Sp-¯p-\o-«n- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ-]-d-ªp.-

]n-s¶- A-Sp-¯- ta-i-s_Â- tI-«p.- Kp-a-kv-X³- A-I-t¯-¡v- sN-¶p.-

""F-tSm- Xm³- ]-Wn-¡-sc- H-¶p- tIm-S-Xn-sbm-s¡- Im-Wn-¨p-sIm-Sp-¡v.-''

]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- ]-Wn-¡-cp- tIÄ-s¡- Kp-a-kv-X-t\m-Sp- ]-d-ªp.-

 

Kp-a-kv-X³- H-cp-]m-Sv- Po-hn-X-§Ä,- k-¦-S-§Ä,- Zp-cm-{K-l-§Ä,- hm-in-IÄ,- B-i-IÄ,- {]-Xo-£-IÄ- F-Ãmw- Iq-«n-sI-«n-b- Ip-td- ^-b-ep- sI-«p-IÄ- Nm-bv-¨p-h-¨v- Hm-t«m- hn-fn-¨p.- ]-Wn-¡-sc-bpw- I-b-än- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bn-te-¡v- bm-{X-bm-bn.-

 

"'C-¶-se- h-¡o-ev- D-d-§n-bn-«n-Ã.- Rm-\pw....- K.L.T. s]-dp-¡n- Rm³- a-Sp-¯p-''.-

]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- I-¿nÂ- \n-¶pw- ss]-k- In-«p-hm³- Kp-a-kv-X³- ]-d-ª- hm-¡p-IÄ- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- a-\-Ê-n-em-bn-Ã.-

ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- ap-¶nÂ- Hm-t«m- F-¯n-b-t¸mÄ- ^-bÂ- F-Sp-¯v- Kp-a-kv-X³- bm-{X-bm-bn....-

""]-Wn-¡-cv- 20þmw- tIm-S-Xn-bn-te¡v- h-t¶m-fq.- A-hn-sS-bm-Wv- \-½p-sS- tI-kp-hm-Zw-''.

Hm-t«-m-¡m-c³ tNm-Zn-¨- 30/þcq-]- H-cp- sR-«-tem-sS- sIm-Sp-¯v- Hm-t«m- C-d-§n-b- ]-Wn-¡À- B-Im-i-t¯-¡v- t\m-¡n.-

""F-s´m-cp- D-b-c-am...- C-Xv- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-X-s¶...- I-®-S-¡p-¶-Xn-\p- ap-t¶- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- I-b-dm³- I-gn-ªp.-''

\o-Xn-bp-sS- A-Xyp-¶-X- t£-{X-¯n-\p- ap-¶nÂ- AXv-`p-Xm-Z-c-§-tfm-sS- \n-¶v- ]-Wn-¡À- B-Xv-a-lÀ-jw- sIm-­Ip.-

 

\m-«n³-]p-d-s¯- In-fn-I-sf- h-fÀ-¯p-¶- Iq-Sp-t]m-e-s¯- en-^v-änÂ- I-b-dn- ap-I-fn-te-¡p-b-cp-t¼mÄ- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- kzÀ-¤-I-h-m-Sw- I-S-¶p-t]-m-Ip-¶-Xp-t]m-se- tXm-¶n.-

B-tcm- sXm-Sp-¯p-hn-«- i-cw-t]m-se- 20þmw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- I-b-dn-b- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- i-co-c-¯n-eq-sS- H-cp- X-Wp-¸p- I-S-¶p-t]m-bn.- X-\n-¡v- ]-\n- h-cp-I-bm-sW-¶v- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- tXm-¶n.- Xm³- \m-fn-Xp-hsc- I-b-dn-b- tIm-S-Xn-I-fnÂ- X-Wp-¸p-­Im-bn-cp-¶n-Ã.- X-s³-d- i-co-cw- a-\-Êp-t]m-se- a-c-hn-¨p-t]m-Ip-tam- F-¶p- ]-Wn-¡À- t]-Sn-¨p.-

 

A-tim-I-N-{Iw- h-¨v- Np-äpw- k-Xy-ta-h- P-b-tX- F-s¶-gp-Xn-b- hr-¯w- P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- X-e-bn-se- Zn-hy- {]-`m-h-e-bw- t]m-se-bm-Wv- Im-gv-N-a-§n-b- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- tXm-¶n-b-Xv.-

""C-Ã..- C-Ã...- C-\n- am-än- X-cn-Ã.''

 

\n-jv-I-f-¦-am-bn- Nn-cn-¨v- P-U-v-Pn- H-cp- h-¡oep-am-bn- XÀ-¡n-¡p-I-bm-Wv.- am-{X-a-Ã- A-t±-lw- h¡o-ev- tI-kv-am-än-b- Hm-tcm- A-h-[n-I-fpw- F-Sp-s¯-Sp-¯v- ]-d-ªv- tI-Êp-sI-s«-Sp-¯v- ssk-Un-te¡v- am-än-h-¨p.-

 

""\½p-sS- tI-kv- 204 B-Wv.- ]-Wn-¡-cv- Sn.-hn.-bnÂ- X-s¶- t\m-¡n-bn-cn-¡-Ww.-''

F-¶- Kp-a-kv-X-s³-d- \nÀ-t±-i-{]-Im-cw- ]-Wn-¡À- P-Uv-Pn-sb-bpw- Sn.-hn.-sb-bpw- am-dn-am-dn- t\m¡n-sImI-­n-cp-¶p.- F-¶n-«pw- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- II-­n-Ã.- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- B-[n-bm-bn.- Sn.hn-bnÂ- 202 II-­p....- ]-Wn-¡À- hn-bÀ-¯p.-

 

""Rm³- C-sX-Ãmw- t\m-¡n.- C-XnÂ- H-¶pw- C-Ã-''.

P-Uv-Pn- h-¡o-en-t\m-Sv- h-f-sc- `-hy-X-tbm-sS- ]-d-ªp.-

""No My Lord... Ext B6 was not properly considered by the courts below'' h-¡oÂ- Xn-cn-¨p- hm-Zn-¨p.-

""A-Xm-tWm- Question of Law. Mr. \n-§Ä- kp-{]ow- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- ]p-Xn-b- hn-[n- I-t­Im?- AIR 2006 SC 1975... F-¶n-«p-]-d.- Rm³- H-c-h-k-cw- Iq-Sn- X-cmw-'' F-¶p- ]-d-ªp- P-Uv-Pn- tI-kv- Xn-¦-fm-gv-N-bv-¡p-am-än.-

 

Sn.-hn.-bnÂ- 203 II-­p.- ]-Wn-¡À- A-kz-kv-Y-\m-bn.- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- X-e- Np-äp-¶-Xp-t]m-se- tXm-¶n.- ]-Wn-¡À- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- hm-Xn-¡-te-¡v- t\m-¡n- \n-¶p.-

 

Sn.-hn.-bnÂ- 204 h-¶p.- P-Uv-Pn- ^-bÂ- F-Sp-¯v- a-dn-¨v-t\m-¡n.- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³d- t]-cv- hnfn-¨p.- D-S-s\- F-hn-sS- \n-t¶m- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- Pq-\n-bÀ- Hm-Sn-h-¶p....-

 

""My Lord, may be after two weeks''

Pq-\n-bÀ- h-¡oÂ- sam-gn-ªp.-

""No... There is nothing in it, both courts below discussed the evidence in detail. Nothing is remaining...''

P-Uv-Pn- Cw-¥o-jnÂ- ]-d-ªp-sImI-­n-cp-¶p.-

 

""No My Lord... may be on next week'' P-Uv-Pn- ]-d-ª-Xv- i-cn-b-Ã- F-¶-Ã...- a-dn-¨v- tI-kv- amän-In-«-W-sa-¶m-Wv- Pq-\n-b-dn-s³-d- A-t]-£.- H-cp- ssI- \o-«n-]n-Sn-¨v- Pq-\n-bÀ- ho-­Ipw- A-t]-£n¨p- sIm-­In-cp-¶p.-

 

""Pass over... at 1.45'' Pq-\n-b-dn-s³-d- A-t]-£- \n-c-k-n-¨v- tIm-S-Xn- tI-kv- 1.-45\p- h-¨p.-

""C-¶p- hm-Zw- tIÄ-¡n-sÃ-¶m-Wv- P-Uv-Pn- ]-d-ª-Xv-.- Rm³- ]-d-ªv- 1.-45\v- hm-Zw- tIÄ-¡m-sa-¶v- P-Uv-Pn-sb- k-½-Xn-¸n-¨n-«pI-­v.-''

 

a-äm-cpw- tIÄ-¡m-sX- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- sN-hn-bnÂ- ]-d-ªv- Pq-\n-bÀ- H³-]-Xp- \n-e-bnÂ- ]-Wn-XoÀ-¯n-cn-¡p-¶- \o-Xn- km-K-c-¯n-te-¡v- ap-§n.-

 

aq-¶v-

 

""Your Lordship may kindly see, there is a pathway on the southern side of the plaint schedule property and it is evident from Ext. C1 Commission report.... Thus the question of easement of necessity does not arise.... But the courts below....''

 

a-[y-h-b-kv-I-\m-b- H-cp- h-¡oÂ- C-S-bv-¡n-sS- I-®-S- I-¿nÂ- F-Sp-¯pw- Xn-cn-¨p-h-¨pw- hm-Zn-¡p-I-bm-Wv.-

]-Wn-¡À-¡v- H-¶pw- a-\-Ên-em-bn-Ã.-

 

""Mr. Counsel, you read the commission report''

 

""A-\ym-b-]-«n-I- h-kv-Xp- ]-cn-tim-[n-¨-XnÂ- B ]-«n-I- h-gn-b-Ãm-sX- th-sdm-cp- h-gn-bpw- ImWm³- I-gn-ªn-Ã-.- sX-¡p- h-i-¯v- Im-Wp-¶-Xv- A-\ym-b- ]-«n-I- h-kv-Xp-hn-s³-d- sX-t¡- A-cn-InÂ- kv-Yn-Xn-sN-¿p-¶- _m-¯v- dq-an-te-¡v- t]m-Ip-¶- h-gn-bm-Wv....-''

 

P-Uv-Pn- h-¡o-en-s\- t\m-¡n- \n-Ê-lm-b-\m-bn- Nn-cn-¨p.-

 

F-Ãm- ssZ-h-§-fp-sS-bpw- ap-J-hp-am-bn- Zn-hy-{]-`m-h-e-b-¯nÂ- Nn-cn-¨p-sImI-­n-cn-¡p-¶- P-Uv-Pnsb- t\m-¡n-bn-cn-¡p-t¼mÄ- ]-Wn-¡À- F-Ãmwa-d-¶v- \o-Xn-\ym-b- hy-h-Ø-sb-¡p-dn-¨v- am-{Xw- HmÀ-¡p-I-bm-bn-cp-¶p.-

 

""X-s³-d- tI-kv- B-Zyw- tI-«-Xv- H-cp- sN-dp-¸-¡m-c³- P-Uv-Pn-bm-bn-cp-¶p.- A-¸o-ep-tI-«-Xv- H-cp- a[y-h-b-kv-I-\m-bn-cp-¶p.- C-¶v- tIÄ-¡p-¶-Xv- A-Xn-epw- {]m-bw- sN-¶- B-fm-Wv.- sN-dp-¸-¡m-c-s³-d- _p-²n-b-tÃ- D-¯-aw... h-b-Êm-bn-sIm-­In-cn-¡p-t¼mÄ- HmÀ-½- \-in-¡n-tÃ...-''

 

A-§-s\- B- t{i-Wn-sb-¡p-dn-¨m-tem-Nn-¨n-cn-¡p-t¼mÄ- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- kz-bw- D-¯-cw- In-«n.-

"'h-b-Êm-Ip-t¼mÄ- ]-Iz-X- h-bv-¡pw....- A-t¸mÄ- A-]-Iz-am-b- hn-[n-IÄ- ]-Iz-am-b- _p-²n-sImIv,- A-\p-`-hw-sImI-­v- hoI-­pw- A-f-¶v- t\m-¡pw.-''

""]Wn-¡-tc- \n-§Ä- F-\n-¡v- Im-ip-X-cp-¶-Xv- hn-[n- ]-d-bm-\-Ã.- tI-kv- hm-Zn-¡m-\m-Wv.-''

X-s³-d- tI-kn-s³-d- hn-[n-bm-tbm- F-¶-t\z-jn-¨p-sN-¶- ]-Wn-¡-tcm-Sv- H-ä-¸m-e-s¯- h-¡oev- ]d-ª-Xv- ]-Wn-¡-À- HmÀ-¯p.-

X-s³-d- \n-Ê-lm-b-X- II-­v- A-t±-lw- Iq-«n-t¨À-¯p.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-tc....- P-Uv-Pn- hm-Zn-bp-sS-bpw- {]-Xn-bp-sS-bpw- hm-Z-ap-J-§-fpw- sX-fn-hp-I-fpw- Xq-¡n-t\m¡n- hn-[n-]-d-bpw-''

 

Iq-Sp-XÂ- sX-fn-hp-IÄ- lm-P-cm-¡n-bmÂ,- A-Xv- hym-P-\m-bm-epw- \nÀ-hym-P-\m-bm-epw- I-\w- IqSn-bmÂ- tI-kv- P-bn-¡pw- F-¶v- ]-Wn-¡-cv- [-cn-¨p-h-¨p.- B- [m-c-W- {]-Im-cw- ap³-kn-^v- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- tI-kv- tXm-äv- A-¸o-ev- sIm-Sp-¯-t¸mÄ- Iq-Sp-XÂ- tc-J-I-fp-am-bm-Wv- ]-Wn-¡-cv- h-¡o-en-s\- Im-Wm³- t]m-b-Xv.-

 

P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- Nn-cn-bpw- Xp-d-¶- a-\-Êpw- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- B-Xv-a-hn-i-hm-kw- hÀ-²n-¸n-¨p.- Hm-tcm- tI-kn-s³-d-bpw- hn-[n- D-S³- ]-d-ªp-sIm-Sp-¯v- P-Uv-Pn- h-¡o-en-s\- t\m-¡n- Nn-cn-¡pw...- h-¡o-epw- Nn-cn-¡pw...- Sn- tI-kn-se-Ãmw- P-Uv-Pn- h-¡o-en-\-\p-Iq-e-am-bn- hn-[n- ]-d-ªn-cn-¡p-¶p.- Xm-sg- tIm-S-Xn-I-fnÂ- ]-e- hÀ-j-§Ä- tI-«p-tI-«p- I-\w- h-¨- tI-Êp-IÄ- F-{X-th-K-am-Wv- C-hn-S-s¯- P-Uv-Pn- hn[n- ]-d-bp-¶-Xv.- A-Xpw- Nn-cn-¨p-sImI-­v.- Xm-sg- tIm-S-Xn-bn-se- P-Uv-Pn-amÀ- h-¡o-en-s\- tNm-Zyw- sN-¿pw.-  tNm-Zy-¯n-\p-thI-­n- tNm-Zyw- tNm-Zn-¡pw.-- Nn-eÀ- tNm-Zyw- am-{Xw- ]-Tn-¨p-h-cpw.- tNm-Zyw- tNmZn-¨v- h-¡oÂ- D-¯-cw- ]-d-bm³- ssh-In-bmÂ- hn-P-b-`m-h-¯nÂ- ap-Jw- Iq-À-¸n-¨p- ]n-Sn-¡pw.-. -h¡oÂ- X-s³-d- ]-Wn-sb- ]-gn-¨v- Kp-a-kv-X-t\m-Sv- X-s³-d- tZ-jyw- XoÀ-¡pw....-

 

]-Wn-¡À- X-s³-d- 33hÀ-j-s¯- tIm-S-Xn- A-\p-`-h-§-fn-eq-sS- ]n-¶n-te-¡v- t]m-bn.-

C-hn-sS- A-§-s\-b-Ã.- P-Uv-Pn- F-Ãmw- tIÄ-¡p-¶p.- h-¡o-en-s\- t]-cp-hn-fn-¡p-¶p.- A-hÀ- ]-c-kv-]-cw- Nn-cn-¡p-¶p.- k-t´m-jn-¡p-¶p.-

 

A-\ym-b-hpw- ]-{Xn-I-bpw- ho-­Ipw- Np-cp-¡n-sb-gp-Xn,- Xm-sg-tIm-S-Xn- P-Uv-Pn-amÀ- A-Xpw- C-Xpw I-In-Ã,- \n-b-aw- hym-Jym-\n-¨-XnÂ- sX-äp- Im-Wn-¨p- F-s¶m-s¡- F-gp-Xn- ]p-dw-¨-«-bnÂ- `-{Z-am-bn- sI-«n-b- Hm-tcm- cI-­mw- A-¸o-epw- P-Uv-Pn- Nn-cn-¨p-sImI-­v- X-Ån-s¡m-­In-cn-¡p-I-bm-sW-¶v- ]-Wn-¡À- A-dn-ªn-cp-¶n-Ã.-

 

\-½Ä- Hcm-tfm-Sv- A-\n-jv-Sw- Im-Wn-¡p-t¼m-gpw- A-Xv- Nn-cn-¨p-sImI-­v,- A-bm-sf- th-Z-\n-¸n-¡m-sX- sN-¿-Ww....- P-Uv-Pn-amÀ- Dale Carnigie s\ hm-bn-¨p- ]-Tn-¨n-cn-¡pw.-

 

s]-s«-¶v- Nn-cn-¨p-sImI-­n-cp-¶- P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- ap-Jw- Np-h-¶p-h-cp-¶-Xpw- A-t±-lw- h-¡o-en-t\m-Sv- I-bÀ-¡p-¶-Xpw- B-Wv- ]-Wn-¡À- II-­-Xv.-

 

""Rm³- dn-hyq- sN-¿n-Ã...- kp-{]ow- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- t]m-Iq...- Rm³- sN-bv-X-Xv- sX-äm-sW-¦nÂ- AXm-Wp- \n-§-fp-sS- sd-a-Un...-''

P-Uv-Pn tIm-]n-jv-T-\m-bn- ]-d-ªv- ho-­Ipw- Nn-cn-¨p.-

 

""C-t¸mÄ- h-¡o-e-·m-cp-sS- ]p-Xn-b- ]-Wn-bm-Wv- dn-hyq- sIm-Sp-¡Â...- F-´m-Wv- A-¸m-c-s³-d-v- F-dÀ- F-¶v- \n-§Ä- ]-d-bq''.

sam-¯w- t\m-¡n- hn-[n-]-d-ª- P-Uv-Pn- hoI-­pw- H-¶p-Iq-Sn- t\m-¡n- hn-[n-]-d-b-Ww- F-¶m-Wv- h¡o-en-s³-d- B-h-iyw.-

 

B- h-¡o-en-t\m-Sv- X-s³-d- dn-hyq-lÀ-Pn- X-Ån-ta-Sn-¡m-sX- ]n³-h-en-¡p-hm³- P-Uv-Pn- D-]-tZ-in¨p.- P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- D-]-tZ-iw- tIÄ-¡m-sX- Xm³- tLm-t-Lm-cw- hm-Zw- ]-d-sª-¶pw- A-Xv- P-U-vPn-b-t±-l-¯n-\p- a-\-Ên-em-bn-sÃ-¶pw- I-£n-tbm-Sv- ]-d-b-W-sa-¦nÂ- h-¡oÂ- F-§-s\- tI-kp- kz-bw- ]n³-h-en-¡pw.-

 

X-s³-d- dn-hyq- lÀ-Pn- PUv-Pn- hm-Zw- tI-«p-X-Å-Ww.- X-Åp-sa-¶- D-¯-a- hn-izm-k-¯nÂ- X-s¶-bm-Wv- sIm-Sp-¯-X-pw.-

""My Lord ground G of my second appeal was not considered by Your Lordship while dismissing the second appeal'' h-¡oÂ- hm-Zn-¨p.-

""None of your grounds were considered. I had only considered the question of law... you had framed only question of fact based on the pleadings''.

 

X-\n-¡v- a-\-Ên-em-Im-¯- s]m-Å-hm-Zw- tI-«v- D-d-§n-t¸m-b- ]-Wn-¡À- H-cp- a-Wn-¡v- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bn-se- ]-Ån-a-Wn- tI-«v- sR-«n-bp-WÀ-¶p...-

Xm³- F-hn-sS-bm-sW-¶p- a-d-¶p-t]m-b- ]-Wn-¡À- I-®p- Xp-d-¶p- t\m-¡p-t¼mÄ- P-Uv-Pn-bpw- h¡o-e-·m-cpw- ]-c-kv-]-cw- t]m-cn-\p- hn-fn-¡p-¶-Xp-t]m-se- sXm-gp-Xv- ]p-d-t¯-¡v- t]m-bn.-

 

tIm-S-Xn- ap-d-n-bnÂ- H-ä-¡m-b- ]-Wn-¡À- A-\v-[m-fn-¨p- \n-¶p.- a-lm-Xv-am-Km-\v-[n- am-{Xw- A-t¸m-gpw- ]g-b-t]m-se- Nn-cn-¨p-sImI-­v- `n-¯n-bnÂ- Xq-§n-In-S-¸pIm-bn-cp-¶p.- 

 

\m-ev-

 

C-cp-]-Xmw- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- X-Wp-¸nÂ- H-ä-s¸-«p-t]m-b- ]-Wn-¡-sc- tam-Nn-¸n-¨-Xv- X-s¶- ko-\n-bÀ- h-¡oÂ- GÂ-]n-¨- tI-kv- Xm³- GÂ-]n-¨- h-¡oÂ- am-än-bn-«p-t­Im- F-¶-dn-bm³- tIm-S-Xn- ap-dn-bn-te-t¡m-Sn- In-X-s¨-¯n-b- H-cp- Xm-Sn-¡m-c³- h-¡o-em-Wv.- Xm³- GÂ-¸n-¨- h-¡oÂ- th-sd- h-¡o-ens\- GÂ-¸n-s¨-¶pw- B- h-¡oÂ- hoI-­pw- th-sd- h-¡o-en-s\- GÂ-¸ns¨-¶pw- Xm-Sn-¡m-c³- h¡oÂ- A-dn-ªn-cp-¶n-Ã.-

 

""km-td- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- Pq-\n-b-sd- I-tIm....- F-s³-d- tI-kp- hn-fn-¨n-Ã....- Rm³- D-d-§n-t¸m-bn.-''

 

''h-¡o-e-p-h-cpw...- D-¨-I-gn-ªv- P-Uv-Pn-bpw- h-cpw'' F-¶v- tI-«-t¸mÄ- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- B-izm-k-am-bn.-

tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- a-Wn-b-Sn-¡p-¶-Xv- B-Zy-am-bn- ]-Wn-¡-cp tIÄ-¡p-¶-Xv- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bn-em-Wv.-

H-ä-¸m-e-¯v- Xm³- ]-Tn-¨- ss{]-a-dn- kv-Iq-fnÂ- 9.-30\v- a-Wn-b-Sn-¡pw.- tZ-io-b- Km-\-¯n-\v- a-Wn-b-Sn-¡pw.- D-¨-bv-¡pw- ssh-In-«pw- a-Wn-bSn-¡pw.- C-hn-sS- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bn-epw- a-Wn-b-Sn-¡pw.-

 

]-Wn-¡À- A-Xv-`p-Xm-Z-c-§-tfm-Spw- AÂ-]w- t]-Sn-tbm-Spw- Iq-Sn- 20þmw- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- hm-XnÂ- Xp-d-¶v- ]p-d-¯n-d-§n.-

k-¦-S-§Ä- B-I-m-i-s¯-bpw- ]q-¡-sf-bpw- a-d-¨p-h-bv-¡pw- F-¶p- ]-d-bp-¶-Xp-t]m-se- sk-¡³-dv- A-¸oÂ- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- hn-i-¸pw- Zm-l-hpw- A-I-än-bn-cp-¶p.- F-¶m-epw- H-cp- N-S-§p-t]m-se- Hcp- Nm-b- Ip-Sn-¡mw- F-¶p- I-cp-Xn- ]-Wn-¡À- hn-im-e-am-b- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bp-sS- h-cm-´-bn-eq-sS- \-S¶v- \-S-¶v- I-d-§-n-Xn-cn-ªv- 20þmw- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- hm-Xn-¡-Â-X-s¶- F-¯n.-

 

F-{X-sb-{X- h-¡o-e-·m-cm-Wv- tIm-S-Xn- h-cm-´-I-fnÂ- \n-¶v- ]-c-kv-]-cw- hm-Zw- ]-d-bp-¶-Xv. X-s³-d- al-Xz-§Ä- hn-fn-¨p-]-d-bp-¶-Xv.- X-s¶-¯-s-¶- s]m-¡n-]n-Sn-¡p-¶-h-t\- s]m-¡-s¸-Sp-¶p-Åq.- X-¶-¯m³- Xm-gv-¯p-¶-h³- C-hn-sS- ho-­Ipw- Xm-gv-¯-s¸-Spw-. h-cm-´-bnÂ- Ip-«n- h-¡o-e-·mÀ- Ku¬- FSp-¯v- tXm-f-¯v- a-S-¡n-bn-«v- Xm-\pw- H-cp- kmÂ-a-­Im-sW-¶- `m-h-¯n-Â- \-S-¡p-I-bm-Wv.-

 

a-Wn- hoI-­pw- ap-g-§n.-

a-Wn- A-Sn-¨p- I-gn-ªmÂ- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- h-cm-´-bnÂ- B-sc-bpw- Im-Wm³- ]m-Sn-Ã- F-¶p- [cn¨- ]-Wn-¡À- D-S-s\- tIm-S-Xn-ap-dn-¡p-ÅnÂ- Hm-Sn-I-b-dn.-

X-s³-d- tI-kv- 1.-45 \m-Wv- F-¶m-Wv- ]-d-ª-Xv.- F-¶n-«pw- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\- II-­n-Ã.- Pq-\n-b-sd-bpw- I-­In-Ã.- F-¶m-epw- ]-Wn-¡À- sR-«n-bn-Ã.- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bn-se- X-Wp-¸n-t\m-Sv- ]-Wn-¡À- k-\v-[n-s¸-«n-cp-¶p.-

 

P-\-en-eq-sS- t\m-¡p-t¼mÄ- H-cmÄ- H-cp- C-cp-¼p-h-Sn- ew-_-am-bn- ]n-Sn-¨v- h-Sn-t]m-se- \-S-¶p-t]m-Ip-¶p.- F-´m-Wv- C-cp-¼p-h-Sn- ]n-Sn-¨p-t]m-Ip-¶-Xv?- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- H-¶pw- a-\-Ê-em-bn-Ã.-

]I-­v,- H-cp-]m-Sv- ]-­-Ã,- cm-P-`-c-W-Im-e-¯v- cm-Pm-hn-\p- ap-t¶- hm-fp-ta-´n- t]m-Ip-¶- tbm-²m-hn-s\-t]m-se...-

A-Xm- C-cp-¼p-Z-Wv-Up-[m-cn-bp-sS- ]n¶-m-se- ssI-IÄ- B-ªp- ho-in- P-Uv-Pn- I-S-¶p- h-cp-¶p.-

]-g-b-t]m-se- P-Uv-Pn-bpw- h-¡o-e-·m-cpw- F-gp-t¶-äv- t\À-¡p-t\À- \n-¶v- sh-Ãp-hn-fn-¨n-cp-¶p.-

F-¶n-«pw- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\- II-­n-Ã.-

 

h-cpw- h-cm-Xn-cn-¡n-Ã.- H-cp-]m-Sv- Xn-c-¡p-Å- B-f-tÃ.- tI-kv- GÂ-¸n-¡m³- I-¯v- X-¶v- ]m-e-¡m«p- \n-¶v- kp-{_-lv-a-Wy³- h-¡o-ev- F-d-Wm-Ip-f-¯n-\v- ]-d-ª-b-¨-t¸mÄ- ]n-jm-c-Sn-bp-sS- A-]-Zm-\-§Ä- hm-gv-¯n- ]-c-¯n-]m-Sn-bn-cp-¶p.- 

 

]m-e-¡m-Sv- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- A-¸o-ep- \-S-¡p-t¼mÄ- a-cn-¨p-t]m-b- c-­Im-a-s¯- s]-§-fp-sS- a-¡-Ä- I-£n-tN-cm³- sIm-Sp-¯- lÀ-Pn- B-fn-Ãm-sX- X-Ån-t¸m-b-t¸mÄ- A-hÀ- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- X-s¶- F-XnÀ-I-£n- B-bn- lÀ-Pn- sIm-Sp-¯-t¸m-gm-Wv- B-Zy-am-bn- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- \n-¶pw- X-\n-¡v- t\m-«o-kv- In-«n-b-Xv.- t\m-«o-kv- kp-{_-lv-a-Wy³- h-¡o-en-s\- Im-Wn-¨-t¸m-gm-Wv- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\-¡p-dn-¨v- ]-Wn-¡À- B-Zyw- tIÄ-¡p¶-Xv.-

 

""Xm³- H-¶pw- t]-Sn¡I-­-tSm...- F-d-Wm-Ip-f-¯v- \-½p-sS- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\- GÂ-¸n-¡mw.- Xm³- t]m-tII-­.- H-c-©p- cq-]-bpw- ^-b-epw- \-½Ä- A-b-¨p- sIm-Sp-¯mÂ- a-Xn...''-

 

A-©p-cq-]-sb-¶v- tI-«-t¸mÄ- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- hym-[n- am-dn.- sh-dpw- A-©p-cq-]- a-Xn-b-tÃm.- ]n-¶o-Sv- Kpa-kv-X\m-Wv- A-Xv- 5,-000/þ cq-]-bm-sW-¶v- sX-fn-¨p- ]-d-ª-Xv.- 5,-000/þ cp-]- F-§-s\-bm-Wv- sIm-Sp-¯-sX-¶v- ]-Wn-¡À-¡p-X-s¶- A-dn-bn-Ã.- I-£n-tN-cp-hm-\p-Å- lÀ-Pn- A-\p-h-Zn-¡p-I-bpw- sN-bv-Xp.- A-h-Im-in-IÄ- I-£n-tN-cp-¶-XnÂ- BÀ-¡m-Wv- tN-Xw,- F-XnÀ-hm-Zw.-

 

F-¶m-epw- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- t\m-«o-kn-\p- a-dp-]-Sn- sIm-Sp-t¯-]-äq.- X-¸n-s¸-dp-¡n- A-¿m-bn-cw- cq-]- kp-{_-lv-a-Wy³- h-¡o-en-s\- GÂ-¸n-¨p.- kp-{_-lv-a-Wy³- h-¡oÂ- ^-bÂ- A-b-¨p- sIm-Sp-¯p.- ss]-k-bpw-!-

 

F-´m-bm-epw- \o-Xn-\ym-b-]qÀ-¯n-¡v- s]-§-fp-sS- a-¡Ä- I-£n- tN-tcI-­-Xv- A-Xy-´m-t]-£n-X-am-sW-¶v- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- I-sI-¯n.-

 

D-¨-¡p-ap-t¶- Xp-S-§n- h-¨- H-cp- tI-Ên-s³-d- _m-¡n- tIÄ-¡p-I-bm-Wv- P-Uv-Pn-b-t±-lw.- X-Sn-¨v- N-µ-\-¡p-dn-sXm-«- h-¡oÂ- X-s³-d- {]u-V-am-b- Cw-¥o-jns³-d- Kmw-`o-cyw- F-Ãm-h-cpw- {i-²n-¡p-¶ptIm- F-¶v- ]n-¶n-te-¡v- C-S-bv-¡n-sS- Xn-cn-ªp-t\m-¡n- hm-Zw- \-S-¯n-s¡m-­n-cn-¡p-I-bm-Wv.- P-Uv-Pn- Ip¼n-«n-cp-¶v- k-{i-²w- F-t´m- hm-bn-¡p-I-bm-Wv.-

 

""Iq-Sp-X-sem-¶pw- ]-d-bI-­.- Rm³- th-W-sa-¦nÂ- \n-§Ä- c-­Im-a-Xp- sIm-Sp-¯- tI-kn-s\- _m[n-¡m-sX- Cu- sk-¡³-d-¸oÂ- XoÀ-¯p- X-cmw''-

 

""Yes My Lord, that is enough''

A-Xn-\m-Wv- C-{X-am-{Xw- hm-Zn-¨-Xv.- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- hn-P-bw.- sk-¡³-d-¸oÂ- sImSp-¡m-sX-bpw- c-­Im-a-s¯- tI-kv- ap-t¶m-«p- sImI-­p-t]m-Imw.- F-¶m-epw- sk-¡³-d-¸o-ev- sIm-Sp-¯v- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- A-`n-{]m-bw- X-s¶-th-Ww.-

 

P-Uv-Pn- X-s³-d- I-¿n-en-cp-¶- s]³-knÂ- Xn-cn-¨v- ]n-Sn-¨v- kv-sä-t\-m-sb- hn-fn-¨p.-

 

H-cp-]m-Sv- hn-[n- tI-s«-gp-Xn- \nÀ-hn-Im-c-bm-b- kv-sä-t\m- H-cp- Ip-ªp- ]p-kv-X-Iw- a-S-¡n-]n-Sn-¨v- F-gp-t¶-äv- hn-[n-sb-gp-¯m-cw-`n-¨p.-

 

""When the second appeal came up for admision, learned counsel for the appelant submitted that appeal may be closed without prejudice to the contentions raised in the second suit pending before the Munsiff Court Kalpetta. Accordingly by recording his submissions the second appeal is dismissed.''

s]-s«-¶v- h-¡oÂ- Nm-Sn- F-gp-t¶-äp.-

""No My Lord, appeal may be closed''

 

P-Uv-Pn- Nn-cn-¨p-sImI-­v- kv-sä-t\m-tbm-Sv- ]-d-ªp.- ""closed''.

A-§-s\- A-¸oÂ- t¢m-km-bn.-

 

""Dismissal Dw- Close Dw- X-½nÂ- H-cp-]m-Sv- hy-Xym-k-apI-­v.- h-¡o-en\p- ]-d-ªp- \nÂ-¡m-\pÅ- A-h-km-\-s¯- hm-¡m-Wv- ""closed''. "Closed" Dismissal B-bmÂ- h-¡o-en-s³-d- \n-e-\nÂ-]n-s\- _m[n-¡pw.-

 

""\-n-§-fp-sS- tI-kv- c-­Im-a-s¯- tI-kn-s\- _m-[n-¡m-¯- hn-[-¯nÂ- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- hn-[n-¨n-cn-¡p-¶p.-''-

 

I-£n- kw-Xr-]v-X³...- h-¡o-epw- kw-Xr-]v-X³.....- ]n-s¶- P-Uv-Pn-bpw- a-lm- kw-Xr-]v-X³...- A-§-s\.-

tImÀ-«v- Hm-^o-kÀ- A-Sp-¯- tI-kv- hn-fn-¨v- tI-kv-sI-«v- P-Uv-Pn-¡-p- sIm-Sp-¯p.-

P-Uv-Pn- tI-kv- F-Sp-¯v- Xn-cn-¨pw-a-dn-¨pw- t\m-¡n- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- t]-cp- hn-fn-¨p.-

s]-s«-¶v- ]-Wn-¡À- Nm-Sn- F-gp-t¶-äv- ]p-d-tIm-«p- t\m-¡n.- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- h-¶n-«n-Ã.- Pq-\n-bdpw- h-¶n-«n-Ã.-

P-U-v-Pn- tI-kp-sI-«v- a-dn-¨p-sImI-­n-cp-¶p.- AÂ-]w- I-gn-ª-t¸mÄ- H-cp-XpI-­p- t]-¸-dp-am-bn- ]njm-c-Sn-bp-sS- Kp-a-kv-X³- Hm-Sn-h-¶v- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- ]n-¶nÂ- C-cp-¶v- D-d-§p-I-bm-bn-cp-¶ H-cp- sIm¨p- h¡o-en-s³-d- sN-hn-«nÂ- F-t´m- ]-d-ªp.- Sn-bm³- sR-«n-bp-WÀ-¶v- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- ap-¶n-te-¡v- sN¶p.-

 

""My Lord, I am representing the counsel for appellant.. may be on next week''

""No.... No.... You inform the counsel'' F-¶p- ]-d-ªp- hoI-­pw- tI-kp-am-än- ssk-UnÂ- h-¨p.- ""Pass over."

 

""Xm-sg- tIm-S-Xn-bn-em-sW-¦nÂ- C-t¸mÄ- tI-kp- X-Ån-I-f-tª-s\.- C-hn-sS- h-¡o-e-n-\p-thI-­n- tI-kp- hoI-­pw- am-än- h-¨n-cn-¡p-¶p.""-]-Wn-¡À- B-Xv-a-K-Xw- sImI-­p''.

 

""h-¡o-ev- No^n-s³-d- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- hm-Zw- \-S-¯n-s¡mI-­n-cn-¡p-I-bm-Wv.- C-t¸mÄ- h-cpw''.- Kp-a-kv-X³- B-iz-kn-¸n-¨p-sImI-­v- C-d-§n-t¸m-bn.-

 

P-Uv-Pn- X-s³-d- h-e-Xp- h-i-¯p- am-än-h-¨n-cp-¶- H-cp- tI-sÊ-Sp-¯p- hn-fn-¨p.- h-¡o-en-s³-d- t]cpw- hn-fn-¨p.-

""99þse- sk-¡³-d-¸o-em-Wv.- C-Xp-h-sc- A-Uv-an-äv- sN-bv-Xn-«n-Ã'' P-Uv-Pn- H-ä-bv-¡n-cp-¶v- ]-d-ªp-sImI-­n-cp-¶p.-

 

H-cp-]m-Sv- A-¼-c-t¸m-Spw- t]-Sn-tbm-Spw- Iq-Sn- H-cp- am³-t]-S- t]m-e-s¯- s]¬-Ip-«n- h-¡oÂ- tImS-Xn-bp-sS- hm-XnÂ- Xp-d-¶p-h-¶v- tIm-S-Xn-tbm-Sv- sX-m-­-I C-S-dn-s¡mI-­v- ]-d-ªp-:-

 

""May be permitted to withdraw the case".

P-Uv-Pn-¡p- a-\-Ên-em-bn-Ã.-

""F-´v?-''

""My Lord, may be permitted to withdraw the case''

""Yes"

 

""Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that he may be permitted to withdraw the case. Hence this second appeal is dismissed as withdrawn''

\o-­-I 7 sIm-Ãw- Cu- Second appeal ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- ]n-Sn-¨p- \nÀ-¯n-bn-tÃ.- sk-¡³-d-¸oÂ- s]³-dnw-Kv- F-¶v- ]-d-ªv- hn-[n- \-S-¸m-¡Â- ZoÀ-Ln-¸n-¨n-tÃ.-...

 

-h-¡oe-·mÀ- F-Ãm-h-cpw- t]m-bn.- P-Uv-Pn-bpw- tImÀ-«v- Hm-^o-k-dpw- kv-sä-t\m-bpw- am-{X-am-bn- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ.-

]-Wn-¡-sc- P-Uv-Pn-sbm-¶p- t\m-¡n...- ]-Wn-¡À- A-dn-bm-sX- F-gp-t¶-äv- \n-¶p.- ho-­Ipw- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- tI-sk-Sp-¯v- h-¡o-en-s³-d- t]-cv- B-fn-sÃ-¶-dn-ªn-«pw- sh-dp-sX- t]-cp- hn-fn-¨v- P-Uv-Pn- tImÀ-«v Hm-^o-k-tdm-Sv- F-t´m- ]-Xp-s¡- ]-d-ªp.-

 

""C-Xv- after vacation h-t¨m-fq-''

 

tImÀ-«v- Hm-^o-kÀ- X-e-bm-«n.-

 

X-e-bnÂ- Km-\v-[n- sXm-¸n- h-¨- H-cmÄ- D-S³- Hm-Sn- h-¶v- P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- I-tk-c- ]n-¶n-te-¡v- h-en-¨p.- A-t±-lw- F-gp-t¶-äv- ]-Wn-¡-sc- t\m-¡n- ssI-Iq-¸n- sXm-gp-Xv- F-gp-t¶-äp- t]m-bn.-

 

A-dn-bm-s-X- ]-Wn-¡-cpw- sXm-gp-Xp-t]m-bn.-

P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- a-lm-a-\-kv-I-X-bv-¡p- ap-¶nÂ- ]-Wn-¡À- X-s¶-¯-s¶- a-d-¶v- I-®p-an-gn-¨p- \n¶p.

 

A-©v-

ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- I-­-Ik-t´m-j-¯nÂ- X-s³-d- tI-kv- am-dn-t¸m-b-XnÂ- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- ]-cn-`-hw- tXm-¶n-bn-Ã.- X-s³-d- tI-kn-\v- F-´m-Wv- kw`-hn-¨-sX-¶p-t]m-epw- ]-Wn-¡À- A-dn-ªn-cp-¶n-Ã.- Sn.hn.-bnÂ- 4 X-h-W- 204 \-¼À- sX-fn-ª-Xv- hy-à-am-bn- ]-Wn-¡À- IIn-cp-¶p.- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- H-¶mw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- hm-Zw- \-S-¯n-sImI-­n-cn-¡p-I-bm-bn-cp-¶p.- H-¶mw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- Pq-\n-bÀ- t]m-bmÂ- icn-bm-hn-Ã.- ]n-jm-c-Sn- X-s¶- t]m-I-Ww.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-tc,- C-¶p- hm-Zw- \-S-¶n-Ã.- am-{X-a-Ã- C-¶v- hm-Zw- ]-d-bm-Xn-cp-¶-Xp-X-s¶-bm-Wv- \ap¡pw- \-Ã-Xv-''.

""C¶p- P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- aq-Upw- i-cn-b-Ãm-bn-cp-¶p-''.

Hm-t«m- hn-fn-¡m³- Im-in-Ãm-sX- \-S-¶v- X-fÀ-¶v- Hm-^o-knÂ- F-¯n-b- ]-Wn-¡-cnÂ- \n-¶pw- ]njm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- ap³-IqÀ- Pm-ayw- F-Sp-¯p.-

""]-Wn-¡-tc,- Xm³- t]-Sn-¡-­-ItSm- \-ap-¡v- \-Ã- tI-kpI-­v- A-Xv- Cu- P-Uv-Pn-¡p- ]-d-ªmÂ- a\-Ên-em-hn-Ã...- A-h-[n- I-gn-ªmÂ- _-©p-am-dn-h-cpw.- a-sä-bm-fp-sS- A-Sp-¯v--hm-Zw- ]-d-bp-¶-Xm- \-ap-¡v- \-Ã-Xv-''.

 

]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- hm-Zw- ]-Wn-¡À- a-\-Êm- kzo-I-cn-¨p.- H-¶mw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- hm-Zw- ]dª-v- h-¡oÂ- X-fÀ-¶n-cn-¡p-I-bm-Wv.- C-\n- tI-kp-Im-cy-§Ä- tNm-Zn-¨v- _p-²n-ap-«n-¡-­Im-sb-¶v- ]Wn-¡À-¡p-tXm-¶n.- F-¶m-epw- C-¶p- tIm-S-Xn-¸-Sn- Im-Wm-Xn-cp-¶- h-¡o-en-s³-d- hm-Zw- Xp-SÀ-¶p.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-tc- Hm-cm- A-h-[n- I-gn-bp-t¼m-gpw- P-Uv-Pn-amÀ- am-dn-h-cpw.- \-½p-sS- tI-kn-s³-d- kz-`m-hw- A-\p-k-cn-¨v- a-sä- P-Uv-Pn-X-s¶-bm-Wv- \-Ã-Xv.- C-bmÄ-¡v- kn-hÂ- \n-b-aw- A-{X- ]n-Sn-bn-Ã''.

""A-t¿m- \n-b-aw- ]n-Sn-bn-Ãm-¯- P-Uv-Pn-am-cpw- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- D-t­Im-!-'' ]-Wn-¡À- kz-bw- A-Xv-`p-Xw- sImI-­p.-

 

""Ct§m-«p- I-b-dn-hm- ]-Wn-¡-tc-''.

H-cp-]m-Sp- Zq-cw- X-mI-­-n-h-¶- ]-Wn-¡-sc- A-§-s\- sh-dp-sX- ]-d-ªp- h-n-Sm³- ]-än-Ã.- 

 

h-¡o-en-s³-d- B-Pv-R-{]-Im-cw- ]-Wn-¡À- A-I-s¯- I-tk-c-bnÂ- B-k-\-Ø-\m-bn.-

""]-Wn-¡tc,- kn-hnÂ- \n-b-aw- F-¶p- ]-d-ªmÂ- H-cp- km-K-cw- X-s¶-bm-Wv.- A-X-§-s\- F-Ãm- h-¡-o-e-·mÀ-¡pw- P-Uv-Pn-amÀ-¡pw- ssI-Im-cyw- sN-¿m³- Ign-bn-Ã-''.

h-¡oÂ- kn-hnÂ- \-S-]-Sn- \n-b-a-s¯-¡p-dn-¨v- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- ¢m-sÊ-Sp-¯p.-

""Xm-sg- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- kq-£n-¨n-sÃ-¦nÂ- ]n-s¶- tI-kv- ]n-Sn-¨mÂ- In-«n-Ã.- A-Xm-b-Xv- A-Sn-¯-d- \-¶m-bmÂ- F-Ãmw- i-cn-bm-bn-''.

ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- h-¡o-en-\v- Xm-sg- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- tI-kp- \-S-¯n-b- h-¡o-en-s³-d- X-e-bnÂ- Ip-äw- Np-a-¯mw.- C-¶-bm-sf- km-£n-bm-bn- hn-kv-X-cn-¨n-Ã.- A-Xv- a-lm- ]n-g-hm-Wv.- aq-em-[m-cw- lm-P-cm-¡n-bn-Ã.- tIk-p- hn-kv-Xm-c-¯nÂ- a-tä-Xv- tNm-Zn-¨n-Ã.- t{Im-kp- sN-bv-X-t¸mÄ- A-h-s\-s¡mI-­v- h-¡o-ev- A-Xp-tNm-Zn-¨p- h-cp-¯n-h-¨p.-

 

""\-½p-sS- ]-{Xn-I-bn-epw- A-§-s\- Nn-e- Ip-g-¸-§Ä- DI-­v.- am-{X-a-Ã- \-½p-sS- hnÂ-¸-{X-¯nÂ- ]-d-ªn-cn-¡p-¶- km-£n-I-sf- \-½Ä- hn-kv-Xcn-¨n-«n-Ã-''.

 

]-Wn-¡À-¡v- A-½- F-gp-Xn-s¡m-Sp-¯- hnÂ-]-{X-¯nÂ- km-£n-IÄ- D-­Im-bn-cp-¶n-Ã.- F-¦n-epw- h-¡o-ev- tI-kp-]-Tn-¨v- sh-Åw-t]m-se- ]-d-ªp-sIm-­In-cp-¶p.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-tc- A-½- hnÂ-]-{Xw- F-gp-Xn-h-¨-Xp- i-cn-X-s¶.- A-Xv- km-£n-I-sf- h-¨v- c-Pn-kv-{Sm-¡p-¶-Xm-Wp-¯-aw-''.- Nm-b-¡-S-¡m-c³- hm-kp-]-d-ª-Xv- ]-Wn-¡À- HmÀ-¯p.-

""Hm- F-s³-d- hm-kp,- hnÂ-]-{X-¯n-s³-d- X-s¶- B-h-iy-an-Ã- s]-§-·mÀ-s¡-Ãmw- F-s¶- A-dn-bmw. A-h-sc- h-fÀ-¯n-b-Xpw- ]-Tn-¸n-¨-Xpsam-s¡- Rm-\-tÃ....- A-h-c-§-s\- tNm-Zyw- sN-¿m-s\m-¶pw- h-cn-Ã.-''

 

Nm-b-Ip-Sn¡-p-¶-Xn-\n-S-bnÂ- ]-Wn-¡À- A-k-¶n-Kv-Z-am-bn- ]-d-ªp-d-¸n-¨p.-

 

A-½- a-cn-¨v- A-Øn-s]-dp-¡-en-s³-d- A-¶m-Wv- aq-¶p- s]-§-·m-cpw- A-h-cp-sS- `À--¯m-¡-·m-cpw- A-½-bp-sS- h-kv-Xp-hn-s\-¡p-dn-¨pw- ho-Sn-s\-¡p-dn-¨pw- B-Zy-am-bn- tNm-Zn-¨-Xv.-

 

""R-§Ä-¡n-\n- F-´m-sW-¶p-h-¨mÂ- A-fn-b³- X-s¶- X-¶mÂ- a-Xn-''.

aq-¯-s]-§-fp-sS- `À-¯m-hm-Wv- tNm-Zn-¨-Xv.- A-bmÄ-¡v- sF-Iy-ZmÀ-Vyw- {]-Jym-]n-¨v- a-äp-Å- s]-§-·m-cpw- A-fn-b-·m-cpw.-

h-kv-Xp-hn-s³-d- `m-Kw- tNm-Zn-¡-bm-sW-¶v- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- a-\-Ên-em-bn-Ã.-

""Ct¸mÄ- C-hn-sS- sk³-dn-\v- 15,-000/þ cq-]- In-«pw.....- A-Xn-s³-d- a-cn-§n-\v- G-«³- X-s¶- Xo-cp-am-\n-¨mÂ- a-Xn''.

aq¯-s]-§Ä- km-hn-{Xn- ]-d-ªp.- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- Nn-{Xw- hy-à-am-bn.- A-sXm-cm-Lm-X-am-bn-cp¶p.- A-Xp-w- A-½-bp-sS- A-kv-Yn- s]-dp-¡-en-s³-d- A-¶p-X-s¶.-

aq-¯-s]-§Ä- ]-¯mw- ¢m-knÂ- ]-Tn-¡p-t¼m-gm-Wv- A-Nv-O³- a-cn-¨-Xv.- c-­Im-a-s¯-bmÄ- B-dn-epw- aq-¶m-a-s¯-bm-Ä- aq-¶n-epw.- A-Nv-O-s³-d- a-c-W-t¯m-sS- sF.-Sn.-sF.- ]T-\w- ap-S-§n.- ]n-s¶- A-½-sb-bpw- s]-§-·m-sc-bpw- t\m-¡n-b-Xv- sjmÀ-WqÀ- sd-bnÂ-th- kv-tä-j-\nÂ- tNm-dp-hn-än-«m-Wv.- A-½-bv-¡v- X-d-hm-«p-kz-¯-nÂ- \n-¶pw- In-«n-b- 50 sk³-dnÂ- 30 sk³-dv- hn-äm-Wv- s]-§-·m-sc- sI-«n-¨-b-¨-Xv.- A-½-bp-sS- a-c-W-s¯-¡mÄ- ]-Wn-¡-sc- I-c-bn-¸n-¨-Xv- s]-§-·mÀ- A-h-Im-iw- tNm-Zn-¨-Xm-Wv....- thZ-\n-¸n-¨-Xpw...-

 

""F-´m- ]-c-aq......- X-s¶- I-­In-«v- Ip-td-¡m-ew- B-b-tÃm-''.

 

h-¡o-em-¸o-kn-te-¡v- I-b-dn-h-¶- I-£n-tbm-S-v- ]n-jm-c-Sn- tNm-Zn-¨-t¸m-gm-Wv- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- ]-cn-k-c-t_m-[w- h-¶-Xv.- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- a-\-Êv- k-¦-Sw- sImI-­v- \-\-ªn-cp-¶p.-

 

""F-s³-d- ]-c-aq,- \n-§-fp-sS- tI-kv- hm-Zw- tI-«p.- hn-[n- ]-d-bm³- F-Sp-¯n-cn-¡p-I-bm-Wv.- F-´m-bm-epw- A-\p-Iq-e- hn-[n- DIm-Ipw''.

 

]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- B-iz-kn-¸n-¨p.-

hn-[n- ]-d-bm³- h-¨n-«v- C-t¸mÄ- B-dp-am-k-am-bn.- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-hn-[n- ]-d-bm³- 6 am-kw- F-Sp-¡p-tam?-

""Nn-e- P-Uv-Pn-am-cpI-­v.- hm-Zw- tIÄ-¡m³- `-b-¦-c- Xn-c-¡m-Wv...- hm-in- ]n-Sn-¨v- hm-Zw- tIÄ-¡pw- F-¶mÂ- hn-[n- ]-d-bn-Ã-''.

 

]-c-ap- h¨p- \o-«n-b- Ip-td- ]-g-b- t\m-«p-IÄ- A-bm-fp-sS- ap-J-¯p- t\m-¡m-sX- hm-§n- h-¡oÂ- t]m-¡-än-en-«p.- I-£n-I-fp-sS- k-¦-S-§Ä- ss]-k-bm-bn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- t]m-¡-änÂ- F-¯pw....- I-£n-I-fp-sS- hm-in- ss]-k-bm-bn- h-¡o-en-\p-In-«pw...- I-£n-I-fp-sS- \n-Ê-lm-bm-h-kv-Y- ss]-k-bm-bn- h¡o-en-\p-In-«pw...-

A-\ym-bw- ^-bÂ- sN-¿p-t¼mÄ- A-XnÂ- \n-¶pw- dn-hn-j³- t]m-bm-epw- 227 F-¶- `-c-W-L-S-\-bn-se- a-l-¯m-b- lÀ-Pn- -t]mbm-epw- Ip-ªp-Ip-ª-¸o-ep- t]m-bm-epw- h-¡o-ep- Po-hn-¡pw.- A-\ym-bw- am-{Xw- sIm-Sp-¯- \ym-b-¡m-c³- F-{X-sb-{X- lÀ-Pn-IÄ-¡v- D-¯-cw- ]-d-b-Ww- A-´n-a- hn-[n- In-«m³.-

 

Pq-\n-bÀ- h-¡o-ens³-d- kv-Iq-«-dn-s³-d- ]n-¶nÂ- I-b-dn- tI-kp-sI-«p-am-bn- Kp-a-kv-X³- F-¯n...- ]-Wn-¡À-¡-v- Kp-a-kv-X-s\- t]-Sn-bm-Wv.- A-bmÄ-¡v- H-cp-]m-Sv- Im-cy-§Ä- ]-d-bm-\pI-­m-Ipw.- tIm-¸n- A-t]-£- sIm-Sp-¡-Ww....- GÀ-fn- t]m-kv-än-§v- h-bv-¡-Ww....- A-Sn-b-´n-c-sa-t½m- h-bv-¡-Ww....- C-sX-Ãmw- Kp-a-kv-X-s³-d- h-cp-am-\- amÀ-K-am-Wv.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- `m-Ky-w-X-s¶-bm-Wv- Cu- P-Uv-Pn- hm-Zw- tIÄ-¡m-ª-Xv-''.

h-¡o-en-s³-d- a-\-Ê-dn-bp-¶- Kp-a-kv-X³- ]-Wn-¡-sc- ]-d-ªp- t_m-²y-s¸-Sp-¯n.-

""th-W-sa-¦nÂ- AÀ-P³-dv- sa-t½m- h-¨v- D-S³- hm-Zn-¡mw-''.

h-¡oÂ,- Kp-a-kv-X-s³-d- ]n-¶m-se- Iq-«n-tNÀ-¯p.-

""thI-­- h-¡o-te- Cu- P-Uv-Pn-¡v- F-s³-d- tI-kv- a-\-Ên-em-bn-sÃ-¦n-tem.- kn-hnÂ- tI-knÂ- Adn-hn-Ãm-¯- B-f-tÃ...-''.

 

h-¡o-epw- Kp-a-kv-X-\pw- ]-Wn-¡-sc-s¡mI-­v- X-s¶- A-h-cm-{K-ln-¨-Im-cyw- ]-dn-bn-¸n-¨p.-

\n-§Ä- F-´m-tWm- H-cm-fnÂ- \n-¶pw- In-«p-hm³- B-{K-ln-¡p-¶-Xv- A-Xv- A-bm-sf- sImI-­p-X-s¶- ]-dn-bn-¸n-¨mÂ- ss{]-a-dn- F-hn-U³-kv- X-s¶..-

""A-\ym-b-¡mÀ- {]-Xn-bp-sS- k-tlm-Z-cn-am-cm-Wv.- A-\ym-b-]-«n-I- h-kv-Xp- hm-Zn-{]-Xn-I-fps-S- A½ t-Zh-Inbp-sS t]-cn-ep-Å-Xpw- A-½ -bm-sXm-cp-hn-[- a-c-W-]-{X-hpw- F-gp-Xn- h-bv-¡m-s-X- a-cn-¨p-t]m-bn-«p-Å-Xp-am-Wv.....- A-\ym-b-]-«n-I- h-kv-Xp-hn-s³-d- \m-en-sem-¶p-ho-Xw- sj-b-dp-IÄ- hm-Zn-IÄ¡v- A-h-Im-i-s¸-«-Xm-Wv...- ]-e-X-h-W- B-h-iy-s¸-«n-«pw- B-b-Xv- \Â-]p-\nÂ-]-\p-k-cn-¨v- `m-Kn-¨p- X-cp-hm³- {]Xn- Iq-«m-¡m-¯-Xm-Ip-¶p...-''

 

F-d-Wm-Ip-f-¯p- \n-¶pw- ]m-k-©À- s{S-bn³- I-b-dn- sjmÀ-Wq-cnÂ- C-d-§p-t¼mÄ- k-tl-m-Z-cn-amÀ- H-ä-¸m-ew- ap-³-kn-^v- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- 33 hÀ-jw- ap-¼v- sIm-Sp-¯- A-\ym-b-¯n-se- hm-N-I-§Ä- am{X-am-bn-cp-¶p- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- a-\-ÊnÂ.

 

B-dv-

A-h-[n-I-gn-ªv- ]-Wn-¡À- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-¡p- ]p-d-s¸-«-Xv- a-\-ÊnÂ- Xo-bp-am-bm-Wv.- A-h-[n- Zn-\-¯nÂ- H-cp-\mÄ- X-s³-d- `q-an- A-f-¶p- Xn-cn-¡m³- H-ä-¸m-ew- ap³-kn-^v- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- \n-¶pw- I-½o-j-\pw- ]-cn-hm-c-§-fpw- F-¯n-bn-cp-¶p.- Iq-sS- aq-¯-s]-§-fp-sS- `À-¯m-hpw.- A-½-bp-sS- Nn-X-h-¨- Ø-ew- h-kv-Xp- \m-em-bn- Xn-cn-¨-t¸mÄ- c-­-Ih-Im-i-n-IÄ-¡m-bn.- A-½-sb-t¸m-epw- ]-Ip-s¯-Sp-¡p-¶- a-¡Ä...-

 

A-h-[n- Zn-h-kw- I-½o-j³- h-cp-¶- Im-cyw- ]-Wn-¡À- A-dnªn-cp-¶n-Ã.- I-½o-j-s\-bpw- ]-cn-hm-c-§-sf-bpw- II-­v- ]-cn-{`-an-¨v- hm-kp-hn-s³-d- I-S-bnÂ- H-ä-cq-]- Xp-«v- C-«v- H-ä-¸m-e-s¯- h-¡o-en-s\- hn-fn-¨p.-

 

""t]-Sn-t¡I-­- ]-Wn-¡-tc...- A-hÀ- A-f-¶p-t]m-I-s«...- C-\n- H-cp-]m-Sv- \-S-]-Sn-IÄ- _m-¡n-bpI-­v- \n-§-sf- C-d-¡n-sbm-¶pw- hn-Sn-Ã....-''.

 

h-¡o-ev- h-f-sc- em-L-h-t¯m-sS- a-dp-]-Sn- ]-d-ªp.-

 

""Rm³- ]-d-ª-X-tÃ- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- \n-¶pw- kv-tä- D-S³- th-W-sa-¶v.- Rm³- ]-d-ª-X-tÃ- F-s³-d- H-cp- h-¡oÂ- ssl-t¡m-S-XnbnÂ-- D-sI-¶v-''.

H-ä-¸m-e-s¯- h-¡o-ep-]-d-ª-Xp- tIÄ-¡m-sX- ]m-e-¡m-s«- h-¡o-ep- ]-d-ªn-«m-Wv- ]n-jm-c-Snsb- GÂ-¸n-¨-Xv-.- A-Xn-\p-Å- a-dp-]-Sn-bm-Wn-t¸mÄ- In-«n-b-Xv-. Xm-sg- tIm-S-Xn-I-fn-se- F-Ãm- h-¡o-e-·mÀ-¡pw- H-cp- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- h-¡o-epI-­m-hpw.-

 

""F-¶m-epw- t]-Sn-t¡-­-ItSm...- A-hÀ- A-f-¡-s«-''.

 

X-s³-d- {]-Xn-tj-[w- A-dn-bn-s¨-¦n-epw- h-¡o-ev- ]-Wn-¡-sc- B-i-z-kn-¸n-¨-p.-

20 sk³-dv- Ø-e-¯n-cn-¡p-¶- X-d-hm-Sv- N-¶w-]n-¶w- A-f-¶v- Io-dn-ap-dn-¨p.- ho-Sn-s³-d-bpw- A-Sp-¡-f-bp-sS-bpw- D-ÅnÂ-Iq-Sn- A-f-hp-I-bÀ- \o-­Ip....-

 

]-Wn-¡À-¡v- X-s³-d- lr-Z-bw- Io-dn-ap-dn-¨v- ho-Xn-s¨-Sp-¡p-¶-Xm-bm-Wv- tXm-¶n-b-Xv.- tI-kn-s³-d- Ku-c-hw- A-dn-bm-¯- Pm-\-In- aq-¯- A-fn-b-\v- Nm-b- DIm-¡n-sIm-Sp-¯p.- I-½o-j-WÀ-¡pw- ]-cn-hm-c-§Ä-¡pw- Nm-b- sIm-Sp-¯p.-

 

X-s³-d- ho-Spw- ]-d-¼pw- ho-Xn-¡m³- h-¶-h-sc- kÂ-¡-cn-¡p-¶- `m-cy-tbm-Sv- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- A-Xn-bm-b- tZ-jyw- tXm-¶n.- Nn-eÀ A-§ns\-bm-Wv- þ X-s¶- D-·q-e-\w- sN-¿m³- hcp-¶-h-tcm-Sp-t]m-epw- B-Nm-cy-a-cym-Z- Im-Wn-¡pw.-

C-¯-h-W- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- hm-Zw- tI-«v- kv-tä- X-¶n-sÃ-¦nÂ- h-kv-Xp- sU-en-h-dn- \-S-¡pw- F-¶m-Wv- H-ä-¸m-e-s¯- h-¡o-ev- ]-d-ªn-cn-¡p-¶-Xv.- sU-en-h-dn- B-bmÂ- D-S³- ssI-h-iw- In«m³- lÀ-Pn-sIm-Sp-¡pw...- ]n-s¶- ho-Spw- In-W-dpw- A-½-bpw- H-s¡- ]-e-XpI-­p-I-fm-Ipw.-

 

a-\-kn-s³-d- F-Ãm- `m-c-§-fpw- B-Ip-e-X-I-fp-am-bm-Wv- ]-Wn-¡À- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- A-Sp-s¯-¯n-b-Xv.-

""F-tSm- ]-Wn-¡-tc- _-©v- am-dn-bn-«n-Ã...- A-bm-fp- X-s¶-bm-Wv- C-cn-¡-W-Xv...- F-¶m-epw- t]-Sn-t¡-­I....- \-ap-¡-bm-sf- ]-d-ªp- a-\-Ên-em-¡mw.-''

]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- ]-d-ªp.-

""h-¡o-te- A-hn-sS- h-kv-Xp- A-f-¶p- Xn-cn-¨p-I-gn-ªp.- D-S-s\- sU-en-h-dn- \-S-¡pw- F-¶m- ]-d-b-W-Xv-''.

]-Wn-¡À- hn-j-a-k-©n- C-d-¡n-h-¨p.-

""F-tSm- HmÀ-UÀ- 21 s\-¡p-dn-¨v- Xm³- tI-«-n-«n-tÃ....- F-¶m-Â- tIÄ-¡-Ww...-''

h-¡o-ev- Execution \-S-]-Sn-IÄ- B-cw-`n-¨p.-

""HmÀ-UÀ- 21Â- C-Ãm-¯- h-Ip-¸p-I-fn-Ã.- hn-[n- F-§-s\- \-S-¸m-¡-Ww F-¶-Xn-ep-]-cn- hn-[n- F§-s\- \-S-¸m-¡m-Xn-cn-¡mw- F-¶m-Wv- HmÀ-UÀ- 21 s³-d- km-cw-''.

\o-Xn- In-«m³- ssh-In-¡p-¶-Xv- \o-Xn- \n-tj-[n-¡-p-¶-Xp- t]m-se-bm-Wv-....- k-Xyw- I-s­-I¯m³- Ip-d-¨v- h-Ip-¸p-I-tf-bp-Åq.- k-Xyw- \-S-¸m-¡m³- a-e-t]m-se- \-S-]-Sn-I-fpw...-

""]-Wn-¡-tc- Rm³- ]I-­v- H-cp- h-kv-Xp-hn-s³-d- sU-en-h-dn- \o-«n- ]n-Sn-¨-Xv- 16 sImÃ-am-Wv....- Obstruction...... Third Party Claim... A-§-s\- t]m-Ip-sa-tSm...-''

 

h-¡o-en-s³-d- A-dn-hn-s³-d- ap-¶nÂ- hn-\-bm-\zn-X-\m-bn- ]-Wn-¡À- C-cp-¶p.- X-s³-d- tI-knÂ- B-cm-Wv- aq-¶m-a³- D-Å-Xv...- B-cm-Wv- {]-Xn-tcm-[n-¡-m³- D-Å-Xv.- cI-­p- s]¬-a-¡-sf- sI-«n-¨-b-¨p.- Hcp-h-sf- `À-¯m-hv- sImI-­p-h-¶v- ho-«nÂ- \nÀ-¯n-bn-cn-¡p-I-bm-Wv.- cI-­v- Ip-ªp-Ip-«n-I-fpw...- Ip-«n-I-fp-sS- sN-e-hn-\p-In-«m³- sN-e-hp-sI-¶v- h-¡o-ep-]-d-ª-Xp- Im-c-Ww- C-Xp-h-sc- tI-kp- sIm-Sp-¯n-«n-Ã.- X-s³-d- Iq-en-¸-Wn-sImI--­v- F-Ãmw- Hm-Sn-t¸m-Ip-¶p.- C-\n-sb-{X- \m-fp- ]-Wn-sb-Sp-¡pw.- h-b-Êm-b-Xp-sImI-­v- ]-d-¼n-se- ]-Wn-¡v- B-cpw- hn-fn-¡m-sX-bm-bn.-

 

]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- Pq-\n-b-sd- hn-fn-¨v- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- tI-kv- sI-«nÂ- \n-¶pw- ]-{Xn-I- ]p-d-s¯-Sp-¯p.- ]-Wn-¡-cp- tIÄ-s¡- t]-\-sImI-­v- A-Sn-bnÂ- h-c-¨v- D-d-s¡- hm-bn-¨p.-

""A-\ym-b-¯nÂ- ]-d-ªn-cn-¡p-¶-Xp-t]m-se- A-\ym-b-]-«n-I- h-kv-Xp-¡Ä- hn-`-Pn-¡-¯-¡-X-Ã.- hm-Zn-{]-Xn-I-fp-sS- A-½- a-cn-¡p-¶-Xn-\p-ap³-]v- {]-Xn-t]À-¡v- h-kv-Xp- h-l-IÄ- hnÂ-]-{Xw- F-gp-Xn- h¨n-«p-Å-Xpw- B-b-Xv- hm-Zn-IÄ-¡v- A-dn-hp-Å-Xpw- B-Wv...-

]-co-£-WmÀ-°-w- {]-Xn-sb- I-jv-S-\-jv-S-s¸-Sp-¯p-¶-Xn-\p-thI-­n- am-{X-am-Wv- A-\ym-bw t_m-[n-¸n-¨n-«p-Å-Xv....-''

 

]-Wn-¡À- I-gn-ª- 33 hÀ-j-§-fm-bn- tI-«p-sIm-­In-cn-¡p-¶- X-s³-d- ]-{Xn-I- ho­Ipw- A-Xyp-Xv-km-l-t¯m-sS- tI-«p...- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-etÃ- hm-bn-¨p- tIÄ-¸n-¡p-¶-Xv.- tIÄ-¡m-Xn-cn-¡m³- ]-äp-tam...-

 

""]-t£- ]-Wn-¡-tc- \-ap-¡v- hnÂ- {]q-hv- sN-¿m³- I-gn-ªn-Ã.- A-hn-sS-bm-Wv- ]-än-b-Xv-''.

s]-§-·m-sc-bpw- A-h-cp-sS- `À-¯m-¡-·m-sc-bpw- hn-fn-¨p- h-cp-¯n- A-h-cp-sS- km-¶n-²y-¯n-emWv- A-½- B-[m-cw- F-gp-¯p-Im-c³- th-e-¸-s\- hn-fn-¨v- ]-Wn-¡À- t]À-¡v- hnÂ-]-{Xw- F-gp-Xn- h¨-Xv.- -F-Ãm-h-cp-sS-bpw- k-½-X-t¯m-Spw- Iq-Sn...-

C-sXm-cp- \n-b-a-{]-iv-\-ta- A-Ã.-...- h-kv-Xp-X-am-{X-am-Wv-.- ]-Wn-¡À- F-´n-\p- sX-fn-bn-¡-Ww....-

]-{Xn-I- hm-bn-¨p- tIÄ-¸n-¨v- ]n-jm-c-Sn- Igp-¯nÂ- C-cp-Im-e³- ssS- sI-«n.- I-dp-¯-v- \n-dw- a-§n-a-§n- Nm-c-¯n-s³-d- I-f-dm-b- tIm-«v- F-Sp-¯n-«p...-

Xm-sg- tIm-S-Xn-bn-se- h-¡o-e-·m-cp-sS- tIm-«n-\pw- Ku-Wn-\pw- Iq-Sp-XÂ- I-dp-¯- \n-d-am-Wv.- AhÀ- I-£n-I-fn-Ãm-sX- Ip-äw- k-½-Xn-¨p- k-½-Xn-¨p- A-h-cp-sS- tIm-«n-\v- I-dp-¸p-Iq-Sn.- Accused absent.... Applies... Pleading Guilty. tb-ip- {In-kv-Xp-hn-s\-¡mÄ- a-l-¯m-b- hyàn-Xz-am-Wv- Xm-sg-tIm-S-Xn- h-¡o-en-t³-d-Xv.- Hm-tcm- {]-Xn-bp-sS-bpw- Ip-äw- kz-bw- G-sä-Sp-¯v- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- G-äp-]-d-ªv- ]n-g-sbm-Sp-¡-Ww...- sN-dn-b- ]n-g....- h-en-b- ]n-g....- F-s³-d- ]n-g- F-s³-d- ]n-g- Fs³-d- h-en-b- ]n-g....- ssZ-h-ta-!-

 

C-¶v- Kp-a-kv-X³- Ku-c-h-¯n-em-Wv.- A-bmÄ-¡v- I-gn-ª- X-h-W- h-¶-t¸mÄ- H-¶pw- sIm-Sp-¯nÃ-.-  A-bm-fm-Wv- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- ^-bÂ- F-¯n-¡p-¶-Xv.- ^-bÂ- C-Ãm-sX- h-¡oÂ- F-§-s\- hm-Zn-¡pw.- Kp-a-kv-X³- ^-b-ep-sI-«p-am-bn- h-¡o-en-t\m-fw- {]m-bw- sN-¶-^-n-b-äp-Im-dn-s³-d- ]n-¶nÂ- I-b-dn.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-tc- Xm³- 20þmw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- F¯n-t¡m-fq- \-½p-sS- sF-äw- 4 B-Wv-''

h-¡o-ev- X-s¶- ImÀ- Hm-Sn-¨p-t]m-bn...-

 

]-Wn-¡-sc- Pq-\n-bÀ- X-s³-d- kv-Iq-«-dnÂ- I-b-än-sImI-­p-t]m-Im-\p-Å- k-·-\-Êp-Im-Wn-s¨-¦nepw- Im-ev- kv-Iq-«-dn-s³-d- s]m-¡-¯nÂ- D-bÀ-¯m³- I-gn-bm-sX- ]-Wn-¡À- \-S-¶p-X-s¶- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- F-¯n.-

 

20þmw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- F-¯n-b-t¸mÄ- tIm-S-Xn- Iq-Sn- I-gn-ªn-cp-¶p.- ]-Wn-¡À- P-Uv-Pn-sb- B-Wv- B-Zyw- t\m-¡n-b-Xv.- A-t±-lw- ]-g-b-t]m-se- \n-Êw-K-\m-bn- hm-Zw- tI-«p-sImI-­n-cp-¶p.- A-t¶- Zn-hkw- Sn.-hn.-bnÂ- A-¡-§Ä- H-¶pw- ]-Wn-¡À- II-­n-Ã.- Sn.-hn.-bnÂ- I-Spw- \o-e- \n-dw- am-{X-am-bn-cp-¶p.-

 

bp-²-¯n-\v- k-Pv-P-c-m-bn- I-dp-¯- ]-S-¨-«-b-Wn-ªv- h-¡o-e-·mÀ- 20þmw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- \n-d-ªp- \n-¶n-cp-¶p.- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\- am-{Xw- IIn-Ã...- ]-Wn-¡À- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- hm-XnÂ-¡-te-¡v- t\m-¡n- \n-¶p...- h-cpw- h-cm-Xn-cn-¡n-Ã....-

 

G-gv-

]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\- Im-Wm-sX- hn-j-an-¨v- ]-Wn-¡À- Sn-bm-s\- A-t\z-jn-¨v- tIm-S-Xn-IÄ- I-b-dn- C-d-§n...-

H-¶mw- tIm-S-Xn-bn-em-Wv- B-Zyw- t]m-b-Xv.- h-en-b- h-en-b- tI-kp-IÄ- No-^v- P-kv-äo-km-Wv- hm-Zw- tIÄ-¡p-¶-Xv.- h-en-b- h-¡o-e-·m-cpw- A-hn-sS-¯-s-¶- Im-Wpw.-

H-¶mw- tIm-S-Xn ]-Wn-¡-sc- A-¼-cn-¸n-¨p.- cm-P-k-Z-Ê-v....- cm-P-sIm-«m-cw- Fs¶m-s¡- ]-Wn-¡À- tI-«n-«pI-­v.- F-¶mÂ- C¶m-Zy-am-bm-Wv- cm-P-k-Z-Ê-v- ]-Wn-¡À- Im-Wp-¶-Xv.- a-c-¯nÂ- sIm-¯p-]-Wn-IÄ- XoÀ-¯v..- kn-\n-am-im-e-bn-se- t]m-se- taÂ-Iq-Sm-cw...- I-®-©n-¸n-¡p-¶- sse-äp-IÄ...- c-­Ip- PUv-Pn-am-sc-bpw- sIm-¯m³- X-e-bp-bÀ-¯n- \nÂ-¡p-¶- \oÀ-t¡m-en- ]m-¼p-t]m-se- ssa-¡p-IÄ.- hm-Zn-`m-K-¯n-\pw- {]-Xn-`m-K-¯n-\pw- thIn- cI-­p- P-Uv-Pn-amÀ- {]-tXy-Iw- {]-tXy-Iw- hm-Zw- tIÄ-¡pw- F-¶m-Wv- ]-Wn-¡-cp- [-cn-¨-Xv.- h-¡o-e-·m-cp-sS- ap-¶n-ep-apI-­v- ]m-¼p-t]m-e-s¯- ssa-¡p-IÄ.- ssa¡v- th-s­-I¶v- h-bv-¡m³- ]-än-Ã.- tI-kp- ]-d-bm³- F-gp-t¶ämÂ- tImÀ-«v- Hm-^o-kÀ- ssa-¡v- F-gp-t¶-äp- \nÂ-¡p-¶- h-¡o-en-s³-d- ap-¶nÂ- sIm-­Ip-h-¶p- h-bv-¡pw.-

 

ssa-¡p- t]-Sn-¨v- H-¶mw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- t]m-Im-¯-h-cp-sI-¶m-Wv- tIÄ-¡p-¶-Xv.- Xm³- ]-d-bp-¶- s]m-Å-¯-c-§Ä...- X-s³-d- Cw-¥o-jn-s³-d- a-l-Xzw- F-Ãm-h-cpw- A-dn-ªm-tem...- tNm-Zy-¯n-\v- D-¯-cw- ]-d-bm³- ]-än-bn-sÃ-¦nÂ- a-lm-tam-iw.- s]m-§-¨-¡-mÀ-¡v- Iq-Sp-XÂ- D-¨-¯nÂ- hm-Zn-¡mw....- tLm-c-tLm-cw- hm-Zn-¡mw.- tI-kp- P-bn-¡mw- tXmÂ-¡mw.- tXm-äm-epw- Ip-g-¸-an-Ã.- P-Uv-Pn-bp-sS- A-dn-hn-Ãm-bv-a...- \n-b-aw- hym-Jym-\n-¡m-\p-Å- I-gn-hn-Ãm-bv-a...-

 

H-¶mw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- ]-Wn-¡À- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s\- I-­In-Ã.- Hm-tcm- \n-e-bn-e-pw- Hm-tcm- tIm-S-Xn-IÄ- I-b-dn- C-d-§nb- ]-Wn-¡À- H-cp- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- hm-XnÂXp-d-¶v- A-I-¯v- I-S-¶-t¸mÄ- sR-«n-¯-cn-¨pt]m-bn.-

H-cp- P-Uv-Pn- ap-I-fn-en-cp-¶v- I--À¡iambn tNm-Zyw- sN-¿p-¶-Xp-t]m-se- h-¡o-en-s\- N-m-Sn-¡p-I-bm-Wv...-

h-¡o-ev- Xn-cp-hm-bv-¡v- F-XnÀ-hm-bv- C-Ãm-sX- F-Ãmw- tI-«p-sImI-­n-cn-¡p-I-bm-Wv.- C-t¸mÄ- \nÀ¯pw- \nÀ-¯pw- F-¶p- I-cp-Xn.-

 

P-U-v-Pn- X-«n-¡-b-dp-I-bm-Wv.- h-¡o-ev- kn-w-l-¯n-s³-d- ap-¶nÂ-s]-«- am³-Ip-«n-sb-t]m-se- kw{`an¨p- \nÂ-¡-bm-Wv.- k-l-h-¡o-e-·m-cnÂ- Nn-eÀ- B-cpw- Im-Wm-sX- A-h-\v- A-§-s\- X-s¶-th-Ww- F-¶v- k-t´m-jn-¡p-¶p-­v...- A-h-\n-¯n-cn- A-l-¦m-cw- Iq-Sp-X-em-Wv...- A-§-s\...- Nn-e-cp-sS- ap-J-¯v- Z-b-\o-b- `m-hw...- C-\n- A-Sp-¯- C-c- Xm-\m-sW-¶- t]-Sn...-

F-Ãmw- I-gn-ªv- iIm-c-a-g- tXmÀ-¶-t¸mÄ- P-Uv-Pn- B- ^-b-enÂ- A-¶-s¯- hn-[n-sb-gp-Xn....-

""Learned Counsel for the petitioner prays further time for agrument... posted to next Monday..''

]-d-ªp- Xo-cp-¶-Xn-\p- ap-t¶- P-Uv-Pn- ^-bÂ- F-Sp-¯v- Xm-tg-¡n-«p.- tImÀ-«v- Hm-^o-kÀ-¡v- ]n-Sp-¯w-In-«m-sX- s\-©pw-X-Ãn- B- ^-bÂ- amÀ-_nÄ- X-d-bnÂ- ho-Wp...-

h-¡o-en-\v- B-Zy-am-bn- N-{µ-\nÂ-t]m-bn- kp-J-am-bn- `q-an-bnÂ- Xn-cn-¨n-d-§n-b- \o-emw-kv-t{Sm-§n-s³-d- kw-Xr-]v-Xn-bm-bn-cp-¶p.-

h-¡o-e-·mÀ- Po-hn-¡m³- s]-Sp-¶-]m-Sv- `-b-¦-c-am-Wv.- D-Å-h-\v- ]n-s¶-bpw- ]n-s¶-bpw- In-«pw..- CÃm-¯-h-s³-d- D-Å-Xp-w-Iq-Sn- t]m-Ipw- F-¶v- ss_-_n-fp- ]-d-ª-Xp-t]m-se-bmWv- h-¡o-e-·mÀ-¡v- tI-kv- In-«p-¶-Xpw- t]m-Ip-¶-Xpw.- tI-kp-In-«n-bm-tem- F-Ãmw- A-dn-bm-hp-¶- PUv-Pn-am-sc- ]-d-ªp- a-\-Ên-em-¡m-³- F-s´m-cp- ]m-Sm-Wv.- I-dp-¯- tIm-«nÂ- X-s³-d- F-Ãm- A-]-am-\-§-fpw- a-d-¨p-h-¨v- h-¡o-ev- hm-Zn-¡pw.- I-£n-¡p- th-­In- P-Uv-Pn- ]-d-bp-¶-Xv- ap-gp-h³- tIÄ-¡pw...- ]m-hw- I-£n- H-¶pw- A-dn-bp-¶n-Ã.-

 

ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- P-Uv-Pn-amÀ- Xm-sg-tIm-S-Xn-bn-se- P-Uv-Pn-am-sc-t¸m-se-b-Ã- F-¶- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- [m-c-W- am-dn-t¸m-bn-cp-¶p.- No-¯-tI-«v- ap-Jw-am-dn-t¸m-b- h-¡oÂ- X-s³-d- k-l- h¡o-e-·mÀ-¡v- ap-Jw- sIm-Sp-¡m-sX- Hm-Sn- ]p-d-t¯-¡-n-d-§n-t¸m-bn...- ]n¶m-se- ]-Wn-¡-cpw- C-d-§n.-

H³-]-X-v- \n-e-I-fnÂ- I-bn-dn-bn-d-§n- ]-Wn-¡À- hoI-­pw- 20þmw- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ- F-¯n.- A-Xm- C-cn-¡p-¶p- ]njm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- H-¶mw- \n-c-bnÂ.- ap-J-¯v- B-Xv-a-hn-izm-kw...- A-dn-hn-Ãm-¯- P-Uv-Pn-sb- ]-Tn-¸n-¡m³- h-¶- A-²ym-]-I-s³-d- cq-]-am-Wv- h-¡o-en-\v.- 

 

D-¨-¡v- tIm-S-Xn-]n-cn-bm³- a-Wn- A-Sn-¨p.- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- Nm-Sn- F-gp-t¶-äp.-

 

""My Lord, item No.4.... It was not represented... I was little late...''

 

""A-sX- B-cpw- D-­Im-bn-cp-¶n-Ã.- It is dismissed for default. You file MJC, I shall consider....'' F-¶p- ]-d-ªp- ap-gp-an-¸n-¡m-sX- P-Uv-Pn- F-gp-t¶-äp-t]m-bn....-

 

Xn-cn-ªp- ]p-d-t¯-¡n-d-§m³- Xp-S-§n-b- h-¡oÂ- ]-Wn-¡-sc-bm-Wv- II-­-Xv.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-sc,- P-Uv-Pn- MJC sIm-Sp-¡m³- ]-d-ªn-cn-¡p-I-bm-Wv...-''

H-cp- a-Wn-¡v- `-£-Ww- I-gn-¨n-sÃ-¦nÂ- Kym-kv-{S-_nÄ- h-cp-¶- ]n-jm-c-Sn- th-K-¯nÂ- \-S-¶-I¶p.-

]-Wn-¡À-¡v- H-¶pw- a-\-Ên-em-bn-Ã.-

 

F-«v-

""ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- \n-¶pw- kv-tä- HmÀ-UÀ- C-Ãm-sX- sN-¶- ]-Wn-¡-sc- H-ä-¸m-ew- h-¡oÂ- imkn-¨p.- ss^-\Â- Un-{In- B-¹n-t¡-j-s³-d- A-´n-a-L-«w- F-¯n-¡-gn-ªp.- h-kv-Xp- A-f-¶p- Xncn-¨p.- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- ]-d-ªp- ]-Tn-¸n-¨- Order 21 s\-¡p-dn-¨v- ]-d-b-W-sa-¶pI-­m-bn-cp-¶p.- ]t£- ]-Wn-¡À- B- [n-¡m-cw- Im-Wn-¨n-Ã.-

 

""\-ap-¡v- AÂ-]w- Iq-Sn- \o-«n- ]n-Sn-¡m-³- I-gn-tbzm-.''

]-Wn-¡À- hn-\-bm-\zn-X-\m-bn- tNm-Zn-¨p.-

""F-t´m-¶p-h-¨m- \o-«n-]n-Sn-¡-W-Xv.- F-s³-d- A-Nv-O³- {]m-Iv-So-kv- Xp-S-§n-b-t¸mÄ- D-Å- tIÊm. A-Nv-O³- a-cn-¨n-«v- hÀ-jw- 5 B-bn-.''

H-ä-¸m-ew- h-¡oÂ- hym-Ip-e-Nn-¯-\m-bn.-

 

]-Wn-¡-cpw- H-cp- \n-an-jw- au-\w- sImI-­p.- Hcp- \-Ã- h-¡o-em-hm³- _p-²n-ap-«n-Ã-tS-m- ...- A-²zm-t\mw- AÀ-¸-tWmw- a-\-Êpw- a-Xn...- \-Ã- a-\p-jy-\m-Im-\m- _p-²n-ap-«v F-¶p- ]-d-ªv- A-Nv-O³- h-¡o-em-Wv.- H-cn-¡-epw- ss]-k- tNm-Zn-¨p- hm-§m-¯- A-Nv-O³- h-¡o-en-s\-¡p-dn-t¨-mÀ-¯-t¸mÄ- ]-Wn-¡À- B-Xv-am-`n-am-\w- sImI-­p.- C-¶n-t¸mÄ- h-¡o-em-¸o-knÂ- sN-¶p-Ib-dn-bmÂ- ^o-km-Wv.- h-¡oÂ-^o-kv.- Kp-a-kv-X³- ^o-kv.- tImÀ-«p-^o-kv...- F-¶p- Xp-S-§n- h-¡o-en-s³-d-bpw- Kp-a-kv-X-s³-d-bpw- t£-a-\n-[n-bn-te-¡p-h-sc- I-£n- ]-Ww- A-S-bv-¡-Ww.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-tc,- h-¡o-e-·mÀ- a-äp-Å-h-cp-sS- sXm-gnÂ- kv-Yn-c-X-bv-¡pw- A-h-cp-sS- th-X-\-¯n-\pw- tPm-en- k-a-b-¯n-\pw- thI-­n-sbm-s¡- hm-Zn-¡pw...- ]-t£- h-¡o-en-\v- am-{Xw- sXm-gnÂ- kv-Yn-c-X-bpw- kv-Yn-cw- th-X-\-hpw- H-¶p-an-Ã-''

X-s³-d- I-¿nÂ- \n-¶pw- \q-dp-cq-],- tI-kp-am-än-b- h-I-bnÂ,- In-«p-hm³- ]m-e-¡m-s«- H-cp- sIm-¨p-h-¡oÂ- ]-Wn-¡-tcm-Sv- ]-d-ª-Xv- ]-Wn-¡À- a-d-¶n-«n-Ã.-

""A-hn-sS- MJC sIm-Sp-¡m³- ]-d-ªn-cn-¡p-I-bm-Wv.- A-Sp-¯-bm-gv-N- B- lÀ-Pn- sIm-Sp-¡m-\m- ]n-jm-c-Sn-h-¡oÂ- ]-d-ª-Xv-.''

]-Wn-¡À- ]-d-sª-m-¸n-¨p.-

 

MJC F-´m-sW-¶v- H-ä-¸m-ew- h-¡o-en-\v- a-\-Ên-em-Im-Xn-cp-¶-Xv- `m-Kyw.- A-Xn-t¸mÄ- BÀ-¡mWv- A-dn-bp-¶-Xv.- {In-kv-Xym-\n-IÄ- Cu-ti-m- a-dn-bw- Hu-tk-¸v- F-¶v- Np-cp-¡n- JMJ F-s¶m-s¡- F-gp-XnI-­n-«pI-­v.- A-Sp-¯- Im-e-¯v- {]-Xy-£-s¸-«- MJC ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- \n-b-a-N-«-§-fn-epw- \-S-]-Sn-I-fn-ep-sam-¶pw- IIXm-bn- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-ep-t]m-epw- HmÀ-¡p-¶n-Ã.- H-cp- Zn-h-kw- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- ^-b-enw-Kv- sk-Iv-j-\nÂ- \n-¶pw- a-S-§n-h-¶- Kp-a-kv-X-\m-Wv- MJC sIm-Sp-¡-W-sa-¶v- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h¡o-en-t\m-Sv- ]-d-ª-Xv.- B-fn-Ãm-sX- X-Ån-t]m-Ip-¶- lÀ-Pn-IÄ- Xn-cn-sI-sb-Sp-¡m-\p-Å- lÀ-Pn¡v- A-§-s\- MJC F-¶v- t]-cp- h-¶p...- A-§-s\....- k-Ôy-bm-bn....- D-j-Êm-bn....- MJC DI-­m-bn.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-tc- \-ap-¡p- t\m-¡mw.- Xm³- t]-Sn-¡m-sX- t]m-tSm.''

H-ä-¸m-ew- h-¡oÂ- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- BXv-a-ss[-cyw- ]-IÀ-¶p-sIm-Sp-¯p.-

 

H-cp- k-t´m-j-¯n-\v- ]-Wn-¡À- h-¨p- \o-«n-b- ]-Ww- h-¡oÂ- hm-§n- ]p-kv-X-I-¯n-s³-d- A-Sn-bnÂ- h-¨p.- I-£n-bp-sS- ap-¶nÂ- h-¨v- F-§-s\-bm- ss]-k- F-®n- t\m-¡p-¶-Xv.- I-£n-t]m-bn- I-gn-ªmÂ- B-Zyw- F-Sp-¯v- BÀ-¯n-tbm-sS- A-Xv- h-¡oÂ- F-®n-t\m-¡pw.-

 

""]-Wn-¡-sc- F-Ãm- A-h-[n-¡pw- Hm-^o-knÂ- h-c-Ww...- h-cm-Xn-cn-¡-cp-Xv....- \-½p-sS- tI-kv- A-´n-a-L-«-¯n-em-Wv-.''

 

]-Wn-¡À-¡v- B- H-cp- \nÀ-t±-i-¯n-s³-d- B-h-iyw- D-­Im-bn-cp-¶n-Ã.- X-s³-d- tI-kv- ]-Wn-¡-cnÂ- H-cp- t{]-X-_m-[-t]m-se- B-th-in-¨n-«v- 33 hÀ-j-am-bn.- Xm³- h-fÀ-¯n- h-ep-Xm-¡n- sI-«n-¨-b-¨- s]-§-·mÀ- sIm-Sp-¯- tI-kv- hm-in-tbm-sS- X-s¶-bm-Wv- ]-Wn-¡À- t\-cn-«-Xv.- 

""\n-§Ä- lm-P-cm-¡n-bn-cn-¡p-¶- Cu- hnÂ-]-{Xw- Ir-{Xn-a-am-sW-¶v- hm-Zn-IÄ- ]-d-bp-¶p-.''

t{Im-kv- hn-kv-Xm-c-¯nÂ- s]-§-·m-cp-sS- h-¡oÂ- tNm-Zn-¨-t¸mÄ- ]-Wn-¡À- au-\w- sIm-­ImW-Xn-s\- t\-cn-«-Xv.-

 

B- au-\w- am-{X-am-Wv- X-\n-¡p- t\-cn-«- ho-gv-N.- {]-Xn-bp-sS- au-\w- hm-Zn-¡-\p-Iq-e-am-bn- ap³-kn^v- tIm-S-Xn- I-sI-¯n.- A-½- X-\n-s¡-gp-Xn-X-¶- hnÂ-]-{Xw- Ir-{Xn-aam-sW-¶v- tIm-S-Xn- ]-dªp.- A-§-s\-sbm-cp- hnÂ-]-{Xw- {]-Xn- N-a-¨p-­Im-¡n-b-Xm-sW-¶pw- Iq-«n-tNÀ-¯p.- ap-\-kn-^v- tIm-S-Xn-bpsS- hn-[n- A-´n-a-hn-[-n-b-sÃ-¶- Xn-cn-¨-dn-hv- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- ap-¶nÂ- hy-h-lm-c-¯n-s³-d- ]p-Xn-b- N{I-hm-f-§Ä- Xp-d-¶n-«p...-

 

H-¼-Xv-

MJC lÀ-Pn- hm-Z-¯n-\p- h-¶p.- MJC lÀ-Pn-¡-v- hm-Zw- D-t­Im?- MJC ]-cn-K-W-\-¡p- h-cp-¶- Znh-kw- ]-Wn-¡À- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- F-¯n.- MJC \-¼À- C«p-In-«m³- Xm³-s]-«- ]-¦-¸m-Sn-s\-¡p-dn-¨v- Kp-a-kv-X³- tIm-S-Xn- h-cm-´-bnÂ- h-¨v- ]-Wn-¡-tcm-Sv- ]-d-ªp.-

 

F-s´-Ãmw- Defect I-fm-Wv.- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn-bnÂ- Defect II-­p-]n-Sn-¡m-\p-Å- H-cp- h-Ip¸p- Xs¶-bpI-­v.- ^-b-enw-Kv- sk-Iv-j³- A-Y-hm- Defect finding section. lÀ-Pn- G-Xp- th-W-sa¶v- A-h-cm-Wv- Xo-c-pam-\n-¡p-¶-Xv.- 50 hÀ-j-s¯- X-s³-d- A-\p-`-hw-sImI-­v- h-¡oÂ- F-gp-Xn-s¡m-Sp-¯- lÀ-Pn- ^-ben-Mv- sk-£-\nÂ- Defect A-Sn-¡-pw...- a-S-¡pw...- ]n-s¶- sk-Iv-j³-ImÀ- Kp-a-kv-X\v- Dictation sIm-Sp-¡pw.- ]m-hw- Kp-a-kv-X³- lÀ-Pn- \-¼À- sN-bv-Xp-In-«m³- a-\-Êm-hm-Nm- A-X-\p-k-cn¡pw.- \-¼À- sN-¿n-¨v- ^-b-enw-Kv- F-¶- a-l-¯m-b- X-s³-d- Ir-Xyw- Kp-a-kv-X-³- ]qÀ-¯-n-bm-¡pw.-

 

""X-s³-d- X-e-bv-¡-I-¯v- a-®mwI-«-bm-tWm...- F-tSm- A-¸o-em-bn- h-cm-\-tÃ- Rm-\m- h-Ip-¸v- F-gp-Xn-b-Xv...- CRP B-bn- h-¶mÂ- B- P-Uv-Pn- X-Ån-¯-cpw...- X-s³-d...-''

ssh-In-«v- Kp-a-kv-X-s³-d- A-¸q-¸-s\- ap-XÂ- h-¡o-ev- hn-fn-¡p-t¼m-gm-Wv- X-s³-d- B-X-v-amÀ-°-X- sh-dp-sX- B-b-tÃm- F-¶v- Kp-a-kv-X³- Xn-cn-¨-dn-bp-¶-Xv.- P-Uv-Pn-sb- t\m-¡n-bm-Wv- h-¡oÂ- lÀ-Pn- X¿m-dm-¡n-b-sX-¶v- ]m-hw- Kp-a-kv-X-\p-t­Im- A-dn-bp-¶p...-

 

MJC hm-Zw- ]-d-bp-hm³- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- Pq-\-n-b-dm-Wv- h-¶-Xv.- Pq-\n-bÀ- h-¡oÂ- MJC lÀ-Pn- F-Sp-¯v- hm-bn-¨p- t\m-¡n.-

""....-]-Wn-¡À- \n-jv-I-f-¦-am-bn- k-Xyw- sN-bv-Xp- t_m-[n-¸n-¡p-¶- k-Xy-hm-Mv-aq-ew...''

"".....-Kp-a-kv-X³- en-kv-äp- t\m-¡n-b-XnÂ- hogv-N- ]-än-b-Xn\mÂ-....-''

h-¡o-en-s³-d- ho-gv-N-IÄ-¡v- Ip-äw- G-äp-]-d-ª-v- lÀ-Pn-IÄ- Xn-cn-s¨-Sp-¡p-¶-h³- Kp-a-kv-X³....-

A-¶v- ]-Xn-hn-epw- tIm-]n-jv-T-\m-bm-Wv- P-Uv-Pn-sb- I-­-IXv.- 

 

tIm-]w- A-dn-hn-Ãm-bv-a- a-d-¨p-]n-Sn-¡m-\p-Å- B-bp-[-am-sW-¶v- B-cm-Wv- ]-d-ª-Xv... Nn-e-cp-sS- au-\w- hn-Zzm-s³-d- `q-j-W-a-Ã...- au-\w- A-dn-hn-s³-d- e-£-W-hp-a-Ã...- A-dn-hn-Ãm-bv-a-bp-sS- B-h-c-W-hp-a-Ã.....- Nn-e- h-¡o-e-·mÀ- C-§-s\- tIm-]n-jv-T-·m-cm-bn- C-cn-¡p-¶-Xv- Pm-V-sIm-sIm-¶p-a-Ã....- Adn-hn-Ãm-bv-a- sIm-­Ip- Iq-Sn-bm-tWm?

 

]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- tI-kp- hn-fn-¨-t¸mÄ- h-f-sc- hn-\-bm-\zn-X-\m-bn- Pq-\n-bÀ- ap-¶n-te-¡p- sN-¶p..- I-dp-¯- tIm-«n-s³-d- D-ÅnÂ- \n-¶pw- H-cp- bm-N-I³- ]-p-d-¯p-h-¶p..- tI-kv- X-Ån-b-Xn-t\-¡mÄ- em-L-h-t¯m-sS-bm-Wv- MJC A-\p-h-Zn-¨-Xv...-

""F-´n-\m- h-¡o-te...- C-§-s\- sh-dp-sX- \o-«n- sIm-­Ip-t]m-Ip-¶-Xv.... There is nothing in it .... there is no substantial question of law.''

 

MJC A-\p-h-Zn-¨v- P-Uv-Pn- ]-d-ªp.-

""My Lord, may be posted for admission on Friday.''

h-¡o-en-s³-d- hm-Zw- P-Uv-Pn- Aw-Ko-I-cn-¨p.- tI-kv- sh-Ån-bm-gv-N-t¯-¡v- am-än.-

X-s³-d- Zu-Xyw- Ir-Xy-am-bn- \nÀ-h-ln-¨- Pq-\n-bÀ- hn-P-b-{io-em-fn-X-\m-bn- ]p-d-t¯-bv-t¡m-Sn-. ]n-¶m-se- ]-Wn-¡-cpw- Hm-Sn.-

""\-½p-sS- MJC A-\p-h-Zn-¨p-'' Pq-\n-bÀ- A-dn-bn-¨p.-

 

]-Wn-¡À- B-\-µ-Xpµ-n-en-X-\m-bn...- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- X-s³-d- MJC A-\p-h-Zn-¨n-cn-¡p-¶p.- ssh-In-«v- h-¡o-em-^o-knÂ- \n-¶pw- ]-Wn-¡À- a-S-§n-b-Xv- ]-n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- H-ä-]m-ew- h-¡o-en-\p- sImSp-¡p-hm³- F-gp-Xn-b- I-¯p-am-bn-«m-bn-cp-¶p.- A-XnÂ- C-{]-Im-cw- F-gp-Xn-bn-cp-¶p.-

 

Dear Sir,

]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- A-¸o-enÂ- sh-Ån-bm-gv-N- hm-Zw-tIÄ-¡pw.- Cu- A-¸oÂ- \-¼À- tIm-S-Xn-bnÂ-

t_m-[n-¸n-¨v- Execution \-S-]-Sn-IÄ- AÂ-]w-Iq-Sn- \o-«n-]n-Sn-¡p-a-tÃm.-

 

hn-iz-kv-X-X-tbm-sS,-

           H-¸v)-

 

]-¯v-

]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-en-s³-d- I-¯v- ssl-t¡m-S-Xn- HmÀ-U-dn-\p- Xp-ey-am-bm-Wv- ]-Wn-¡-cp- I-­-IXv.- \n-d-ª- B-Xv-a- \nÀ-hr-Xn-tbm-sS- bp-²w- P-bn-¨- tbm-²m-hn-s\-t¸m-se- ho-«nÂ-h-¶p- I-b-dn-b- ]-Wn-¡À- a-\-Êp-\n-d-sb- `m-c-y-sIm-Sp-¯- `-£-Ww- I-gn-¨p--d-§m³- In-S-¶p.-

 

\m-ep- I-j-W-§-fm-bn- A-f-¶p- Xn-cn-¨n-«n-cn-¡p-¶- A-\ym-b-¸-«-n-I- h-kv-Xp-hn-s³-d- A-Xn-cp-I-fnÂ- ]-Wn-¡-cp- h-¨p- ]n-Sn-¸n-¨- a-c-¨n-Ã-I-fnÂ- ]n-tä-¶p-w- ]-Xn-hp-t]m-se- Im-¡I-Ä- I-c-ªp.- \m-«n-se- tIm-gn-IÄ- ap-gp-h³- Iq-In....- ]-Xn-hp-sX-än-¡m-sX- sXm-Sn-bn-em-sI- sh-fn-¨w- ]-SÀ-¶p...- A-¶v- ]-Wn-¡À- am-{Xw- D-WÀ-¶n-Ã-. F-¶pw- \n-kw-K-X-tbm-sS- am-{Xw- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- km-ao-]yw- A-dn-ªn-cp-¶- Pm-\-In-bp-sS- \o-­-II-c-¨n-ep-tI-«m-Wv- ]-Wn-¡-cp- a-cn-¨- hn-h-c-w- \m-«p-Im-c-dn-ª-Xv.-

 

Hm-tcm- h-gn-I-fnÂ- \n-¶pw- Hm-tcm- I-c-¨n-ep-I-fm-bn- s]-§-·m-cpw- A-fn-b-·m-cpw- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- A-cn-In-se-¯n.- A-hÀ- a-\-Ê-dn-ªv- I-c-ªp.- B-Xv-amÀ-°-am-bn,- h-¨p-sI-«n-Ãm-sX- I-c-ªp.- F-Ãm-hÀ-¡pw- th-In- sh-bn-ep-sImI-­p- X-W-te-In-b- h³- a-cw-t]m-se- X-§-sf- hfÀ-¯n-b- tP-jv-T-s³-d- i-co-c-¯nÂ- t\m-¡n- A-hÀ- B-Xv-amÀ-°-am-bn- I-c-ªp.- 33 hÀ-j-s¯- tI-kpw- XÀ-¡-§-fpw- Pbhpw- ]-cm-P-b-hpw- H-¶pw- B- k-¦-S-s¯- _m-[n-¨n-cp-¶n-Ã.- B- a-c-Ww- kr-jv-Sn-¨ iq-\y-X- A-h-sc- hÃmsX- th-Z-\n-¸n-¨p.- A-h-cp-sS- hm-Z-ap-J-§-sf- ]-cm-Pn-X-\m-bn- am-{Xw- t\-cn-«- B- a-\p-jy³- a-c-W-¯n-s³-d- ap-¶nÂ- A-h-sc- tXmÂ-¸n-¨n-cn-¡p-¶p.-

 

G-Xv- \n-b-a-¯n-\m-Wv- a-c-W-s¯- P-bn-¡p-hm³- I-gn-bp-I.....- G-Xv- bp-²-¯n-\m-Wv- a-c-W-s¯- X-S-bm³- I-gn-bp-I....- G-Xv- kv-t\-l-¯n-\m-Wv- a-c-W-s¯- ]n-Sn-¨-I-äm³- I-gn-bp-I....-

 

\m-em-bn- Xn-cn-¨- A-\ym-b-]-«n-I- h-kv-Xp-hn-s³-d- ]-Snªm-td- aq-e-bnÂ- aq-¯-s]-§Ä-¡m-bn- Xn-cn-¨- h-kv-Xp-hnÂ- \n-¶pw- ]-¨-am-hv- sh-«n- ]-Wn-¡À-¡v- Nn-X-sbm-cp-¡n.- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- a-I-fp-s-S- Ipªp-a-I³- B-Nm-c-{]-Im-cw- B- `u-Xo-I- Po-hn-X-¯n-\p- A-Kv-\n- ]-IÀ-¶p.- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- Nn-X- s]-§-·m-cp-sS-bpw- A-fn-b-·m-cp-sS-bpw- hm-in-sb- I-¯n-¨p-I-f-ªp.-

 

F-Ãm-a-dn-ªv- A-½- F-gp-Xn- h-¨- hnÂ-]-{Xw- k-Xy-am-sW-¶-dn-ªn-«pw- X-§Ä- tIm-S-Xn-ap-dn-I-fnÂ- tN-«-s\- tXmÂ-¸n-¨p-I-f-ªXv- A-h-sc- Iq-Sp-XÂ- hn-j-an-¸n-¨p.- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- Nn-X- B-fn-¡-¯pt¼mÄ- F-Ãm-h-cpw- H-cp- \n-an-jw- Ip-ä-t_m-[w- sImI-­v- I-c-ªn-cp-¶p.- X-§Ä- Cu- Po-hn-X-t¯m-Sp- \o-Xn- ]p-eÀ-¯n-bn-Ã- F-¶-hÀ- A-dn-ªn-cp-¶p.-

 

X-§Ä- tI-kp- \-S-¯n- P-bn-¨v- `m-Kn-¨- h-kv-Xp- X-§Ä-¡p-th-­-IF-¶p- Xo-cp-am-\n-¨v- A-hÀ- ]Wn-¡-cp-sS- ho-Sn-s³-d- ]-Sn-bn-d-§p-t¼mÄ- Pm-\-In- \n-Êw-K-X-tbm-sS- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- Nn-X-sbcn-bp-¶Xp- t\m-¡n- \nÂ-¡p-I-bm-bn-cp-¶p.-

 

            ***                ***              ***

sh-Ån-bm-gv-N- 20þmw- tIm-S-Xn-bp-sS- H-¶mw- \n-c-bnÂ- P-Uv-Pn-¡p-t\-sc-bp-Å- I-tk-c-bnÂ- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡oÂ- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- tI-kp- hm-Zw- ]-d-bp-hm³- \n-e-bp-d-¸n-¨n-cp-¶p.- P-Uv-Pn- tNm-Zn-¡p-¶- GXp- tNm-Zy-¯n-\pw- D-¯-cw- ]-d-bp-hm³- X-¿m-dm-bn.- Xm³- kr-jv-Sn-s¨-Sp-¯- Substantial Question of Law bnÂ- ap-dp-sI- ]n-Sn-¨v- [o-c-\m-bn...-

]-Xn-hp-t]m-se- P-Uv-Pn- Nn-cn-¨p-sImI-­v- ]n-jm-c-Sn- h-¡o-e-n-s³-d- t]-cp- hn-fn-¨p.- h-¡oÂ- F-gp-t¶-äv- ]-Wn-¡-cp-sS- tI-kn-s³-d- hm-Zw- Xp-S-§n...- k-Xy-ta-h- P-b-tX-....

The Recent Amendments in Criminal Procedure Code and
Assistant Public Prosecutors - A Comment

 

     (By K.G. Sankaran, Deputy Director of Prosecution,

Directorate of Prosecution, Ernakulam)

 

The Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Act 2005 (25 of 2005) and the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2005 (2 of 2006) after much discussion passed by both houses of our Parliament and received the assent of the President of India long ago. But the implementation of the amended Act was deferred by the Government indefinitely, most probably due to the nation wide protest by Lawyers and the objections made by the Bar Council of India against some provisions, which according to them are likely to affect the interest of the accused. The most objectionable part of the Amended Act as far as the Lawyers are concerned is making obligatory the presence of the accused at the time of final hearing and pronouncing the order of the anticipatory bail application filed by them. The advantage (or disadvantage) of the Amended Act is that once the anticipatory bail application filed by the accused is rejected, the investigating agency is at liberty to apprehend the accused from the court premises itself. The other objection seems to be against the confiscation of the property of the accused who has evaded the process of the case.

 

Whatever may be the objections raised by the Lawyers and others, the Government now was pleased to implement the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2005 fully and the Code of Procedure (Amendment) Act 2005 partially. The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2005 (2 of 2006) except S. 4 has come into force with effect from 16th April 2006 vide SO 523(E) dated on 12th April 2006. The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2005 (2 of 2006) except S.4 has came into force with effect from 5th July 2006 Vide SO 990(E) dated 3rd July 2006. The Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Act 2005 (Act 25 of 2006) except provision under Ss.16, 25, 28(a), 28(b), 38, 42(a), 42(b)(III) and (iv) and 44(a) has came into force with effect from 23rd June 2006 vide SO 923 (E) dated on 21st June 2006.

 

Generally speaking, most of the amended provisions in Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure Code are welcomed by the public at large, especially the amended provision in Criminal Procedure Code, not to arrest a woman after sunset and before sun rise, except under special circumstances that too under a written order from a Magistrate concerned is most welcome to the Human Right Activists and other women organisations. No doubt, the amended provisions will be helpful to a certain extent to under trial prisoners who have been suffering in jail since many years without trial. Provisions like ‘Plea Bargaining’ etc. will also be helpful for speedy disposal of cases and thereby it becomes a major relief for our over crowded courts.

 

But, so far as the Assistant Public Prosecutors in the State are concerned it is doubtful whether amendments made in the Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure Code have done any justice to them. A new provision under S.25 (A) is introduced in the Criminal Procedure Code enabling the State Government to establish a Directorate of Prosecution. The new Section empowers the State Government to establish a Directorate of Prosecution consisting of a Director of Prosecution and as many Deputy Directors of Prosecution as it thinks fit. A person who has been in practice as an Advocate for not less that 10 years shall be eligible to be appointed as the Director of Prosecution and Deputy Director of Prosecution and such appointment shall be made only with the concurrence of the Hon’ble Chief Justice of the High Court. The Director shall be the head of the Directorate of Prosecution and he is under the direct administrative control of the Secretary of the Home Department. It is very sad to point out that if such provisions under S.25(A) is strictly implemented in the letter and spirit, no Assistant Public Prosecutor in the State is going to be promoted as Deputy Director of Prosecution since most of the Assistant Public Prosecutors do not have the required 10 years practice at the Bar. Further, such appointment of Deputy Director shall be made only with the concurrence of the Hon’ble Chief Justice of the High Court. No doubt, such contingencies in the appointment will create so many problems in the way of our promotion to the post of Deputy Director of Prosecution. More over, the Advocates having 10 year practice at the Bar will be appointed as Deputy Director of Prosecution and we the Assistant Public Prosecutors shall ever remain as Assistant Public Prosecutors in our whole service and will be constrained to work under his administrative control. What a pity it is!

 

But we have a ray of hope in the amendment made under S.24 of Criminal Procedure Code. Here an explanation is introduced after the proviso to sub-S.6 of S.24 which reads as follows:

 

Explanation for the purpose of this Sub-section.

 

 “regular cadre of prosecuting officers’ means a cadre of prosecuting officers which includes therein the post of a Public Prosecutor, by what ever name called, and which provides for promotion of Assistant Public Prosecutors by what ever name called, to that post”.

 

 ‘Prosecuting officer’ means a person by whatever name called appointed to perform the functions of a Public Prosecutor, an Additional Public Prosecutor or an Assistant Public Prosecutor under this Code.

 

In this context, it is significant to note the decision of the Apex Court in K.J.John v. State of Kerala reported in 1990 (2) KLT 651 (SC) = 1990 Cr.L.J. page 1777. The Apex Court rejected our prayer for promotion, mainly holding that the Assistant Public Prosecutors do not include in the ‘regular’ cadre of prosecuting officers as envisaged u/s.24 (6) Cr.P.C. and so the Assistant Public Prosecutors can not be insisted on being appointed as Public Prosecutor. Now the legal embargo created by the Apex Court is removed by the legislature by introducing an explanation to the term ‘regular cadre of prosecuting officers’. The explanation specifically says that the cadre of prosecuting officers means and includes all the Assistant Public Prosecutors, what ever name called. So all the legal hurdles in the way of our promotion is removed.

 

Now the ball is in Government Court. Proviso to sub-s.6 of S.24 clearly says that where in the opinion of the State Government no suitable person is available in the regular cadre of prosecuting officers for such appointment, the Government may appoint a person as Public Prosecutor from the panel of names prepared by the District Magistrate. To put it another way the Government may appoint a person as Public Prosecutor from the panel prepared by the District Magistrate, only if, it has an opinion that no person (Assistant Public Prosecutor) in the regular cadre is suitable for such appointment. The Government is the whole authority in the above matter. If the Government says that the Assistant Public Prosecutors are not suitable to be appointed as Public Prosecutor the whole matter ends there and we have no right whatever to challenge it. With due respect, I submit that Government cannot form such an opinion. There are competent, efficient, hard working, trustworthy, experienced Assistant Public Prosecutors in our State. The Government can select such competent person and appoint them as Public Prosecutors. By doing so a long cherished dream of Assistant Public Prosecutors is going to be fulfilled. Will the Government do justice? 

Make Ostracize Crime

S.A. Karim, Advocate, Thiruvananthapuram

Ostracize is not an offence either in our country or any other country. The dictionary meaning of ostracize is to exclude one from society and from one’s social group. Ordinarily it is called ex-communication. Our society consists of religious groups such as Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Parsis, Sikhs & others. Every religion has personal laws. What is not applies on personal laws, applies on general laws. Matters coming under personal laws and general laws can be questioned in a court of law. There are customs and conventions in every religious society. It is unwritten and un-breakable. Usually a selected or elected body is the custodian of such customs and conventions. This is true in all religious societies. Their punishment is ostracize.

A society excludes the ostracized from attending social and religious functions and gatherings. Some times the ostracize affects the members of the ostracized’s family. The pain and suffering of ostracize is immense. Such one cannot approach a court of law, because it is not an offence. One Sheik Sher Mohammed of Bhadrak district in Orissa divorced his wife Najma Beevi in triple talaq-under the influence of alcohol. Later they lived as husband and wife. The Orissa unit of Jamial-ul-Ulama opposed their re-union. The couple fought their battle up to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court directed the Orissa Government to provide protection to the couple. The Jamial-ul-Ulama says, they will ostracize the couple, if they continue to live as husband and wife. This is the latest case reported in the New Indian Express of 24th April, 2006.

According to Jamial-ul-Ulama, the re-union is against Sharia. In the instant case the re-union harms none. Every law is made for the welfare and betterment of the society. Similar is the case with customs and conventions. No man is made either for the law or custom or convention. None shall be permitted to take the law into one’s own hands. So, there needs a law to make ostracize crime.

A Note of Dissent 

 

(By Executive Committee, Kerala High Court Advocates Association)

 

The Executive Committee of the Kerala High Court Advocates Association wish to place on record its dissent on some of the incorrect statements in the article ‘Judicial Grand Canyon’ published in the journal section of Part 12 of Kerala Law Times dated 18th September in 2006 (3) KLT, as the said statements are likely to mislead the readers.

 

The article tends to give the impression that the Lawyers are a hapless lot in the High Court without access even to basic amenities. The Lawyers are provided with all basic amenities and the tube well referred to in the article was erected as agreed to by the Association and as the quality of the water was not upto the mark immediate orders were issued by the Chief Justice, as per which drinking water connection had been provided. Sufficient number of modern water purifier cum coolers are installed at various floors in the High Court building and the Advocates Association has its own water purifier with hot and cold water facility in its premises. The Association also has been allowed to have sufficient number of coffee and tea vending machines at places of their choice. Cooking using charcoal and firewood alone are prevented in the canteen located in the main building on account of excessive smoke that is likely to activate the fire alarm system. In addition to the cafeteria in the new building complex the Association has a full fledged canteen run by the Indian Coffee House in the old Association premises in the adjacent compound.

 

Initially, though vehicles were not permitted to be parked in the new High Court premises, as requested by the Association, the entire front compound of the new building has been exclusively allotted to lawyers for parking of vehicles. Advocate General and other State officials have been provided with space for parking their vehicles. The parking space provided in the new High Court building complex is in addition to the entire car parking area available to the Advocates in the old association premises in the adjacent compound.

 

The intention of the learned author being too obvious, the Executive Committee do not wish to question the same. The opinion of the author does not represent or reflect the collective opinion of the lawyer community in the High Court or that of the Advocates Association. Let not truth be a casualty in vituperative outbursts.

 

We wish the pages of renowned law journals are put to better use.